UK & World News

  • 6 May 2012, 9:59

Alleged 9/11 Plotters Keep Mute In Cuba Court

Four of the five men accused of the 9/11 terror charges have refused to utter a single word throughout their first court appearance at a military tribunal in Guantanamo Bay.

The only defendant at the hearing to speak was Yemeni prisoner Ramzi bin al Shibh, who yelled in a mix of Arabic and broken English at the judge: "Maybe they will kill me and say I committed suicide."

All five accused refused to answer questions from US military judge Colonel James Pohl as he explained their rights and gave them the chance to appoint their own defence lawyers.

One defendant sat leafing through a book, another praying as the judge asked them question after question, and repeatedly noted for the record "defendant refused to answer".

They are charged with terror offences arising from the September 11 attacks in 2001 that killed almost 3,000 people.

Most prominent among them the self-proclaimed mastermind of the atrocities, Khalid Sheikh Mohammed.

He sat in white robes and white headdress with a long, dyed beard and showed little emotion as the proceedings went on around him.

His lawyer and one for another defendant said their clients will remain silent until their complaints about the nature of their confinement are dealt with first in court.

Co-defendant Walid bin Attash was restrained to a chair after refusing to enter the court voluntarily, but was later unshackled after he pledged to behave inside the courtroom.

The proceedings at a US facility in Cuba cannot be broadcast but reporters are monitoring them by CCTV pictures. At one point the hearing was censored for a minute.

One defence counsel said he suspected the censorship was imposed to protect the US government from embarrassment. Another said he believed it was to prevent discussion of the defendants being tortured.

The defendants' silence allowed for little drama. One of the accused had been brought in to the court held down with restraints, but was later unshackled.

The military tribunal was convened in Guantanamo after the Obama administration failed to have the trial held under civilian law on the US mainland in the face of fierce political and public opposition.

Prosecutors say the tribunals have been reformed and are now as fair as federal civilian courts, but others are not convinced.

Former Guantanamo prosecutors and human rights activists have lined up to condemn the proceedings as unable to give the accused a fair hearing.

There is also concern that the accused were subject to coercive interrogation by the CIA and that irredeemably taints the evidence in the case.

Prosecutors say no such evidence will play a part in this trial.

what do you think?

15 comments

Lorgar Aurelian

7:37am on 5/5/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

heneryblackberry

8:24am on 5/5/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 6
2 replies

Name witheld

11:38am on 5/5/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

simon calvert

2:07pm on 5/5/2012

That's a pretty weird thing to say...

Lorgar Aurelian

9:19am on 5/5/2012

Why was my legitimate comment censored?

Score: 3
1 reply

Micky Lyden

10:12am on 5/5/2012

Because orange does not like people to tell the truth

Score: 10

d and d Phillips

12:18pm on 5/5/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

simon calvert

1:02pm on 5/5/2012

Numptys.....how can you torture someone then put them to trial...typical Americans...want both ends of the greasy stick...

Score: 10

jimmyjedi1979

2:39pm on 5/5/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

Name witheld

3:09pm on 5/5/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Ian Stephenson

4:01pm on 5/5/2012

I hate to say this but if he has been waterboarded that counts as torture. I do not want people to torture others in my name this man may be guilty but must not get confessions through torture it makes us no better than those we are supposed to be against!!!

Score: 7

john

5:44pm on 5/5/2012

I remember an American ex-secret service agent being interviewed on radio claiming that he could have the then Home Secretary David Blunkett confessing he was Osama Bin Laden in no less than 5 minutes. He concluded that torture only gave him the answers to the questions he asked and not the truth.

Score: 5

Adrian Wagstaff

6:58pm on 5/5/2012

I ain't seen nothin' yet.

kyle rambo

7:59pm on 5/5/2012

i thought bin laden was the mastermind? *im confused*

Score: 1

james mcbride

8:44pm on 5/5/2012

i thought the main person was osama bin laden? all seems to be a pack of lies backed up by lack of electorate voting in usa/uk.

Score: 7

james mcbride

8:48pm on 5/5/2012

watch press tv and russia today united nations speeches from iran president, also the fact ron paul repub us senator said cia elements did it. the fact iran says usa will do another style 9-11. shows it was inside job. the fact all uk/usa diplomats walked out out un speech by dinner jacket iran pm ba

Score: 4
3 replies

james mcbride

8:51pm on 5/5/2012

the fact russia today publishes the usa did it, then the uk go on about litvenko as he said russia blew up tower blocks for oil and wars in chechnya/caucausus. illustrates it is synthetic terror. done for oil, money and new controlling laws. debate freedom of speech leave up orange. the fact bin laden wore usa combat jacket when he preached hate against usa shows that was old cia footage of him training ppl against russians.

Score: 5

chris

8:39am on 6/5/2012

so are you saying that all the AQ bombings, worldwide, on US embassies/ships/troops/T towers, over the years, were all CIA inspired? or just some of them? They were certainly inspired by someone! It seems odd to me that so many people around the world would dearly love to have a 'Leader' like 'Dinner Jacket' Iranian PM. But he is really just a front man. Ayatollah pulls the strings. The death toll mounts as they chase there dreams of getting or keeping power.

Score: 1

kyle rambo

7:12pm on 6/5/2012

It's too sad if it is. They've destroyed the world. All the innocent, british American Soldiers, all the women and children and men. All for a resource that will only destroy the earth. They call it Black Gold we should it call it the Black Plague

John Henderson

9:04pm on 5/5/2012

Definition of Military Tribunal - "Kangaroo Court". No further comment needed.

Score: 3

jimmyjedi1979

10:00pm on 5/5/2012

Eh?

Score: 2
Advertisement