UK & World News

  • 14 May 2012, 10:29

Amputees May Lose Benefits Under Reforms

Amputees could be among half a million people who are set to lose disability benefits under Government plans.

Those in receipt of the disability living allowance (DLA) may no longer be eligible for its replacement, the personal independence payment, amid plans to slash the cost of benefits by more than £2.2bn.

Iain Duncan Smith, the Work and Pensions Secretary, defended the reforms which could see people without limbs, including ex-servicemen and women, no longer entitled to disability benefits as their everyday mobility is not undermined by their prosthetic limbs.

He told the Daily Telegraph: "It's not like incapacity benefit, it's not a statement of sickness.

"It is a gauge of your capability. In other words, 'Do you need care, do you need support to get around?'... Those are the two things that are measured.

"Not, 'You have lost a limb'."

Mr Duncan Smith told the paper there had been a 30% rise in the number of claimants in recent years, with the annual cost of the benefits soon to reach £13bn.

Under the reforms, two million claimants would reassessed in the next four years and only those considered to be in need of support allowed to qualify.

Mr Duncan Smith said: "We are creating a new benefit, because the last benefit grew by something like 30% in the past few years.

"It's been rising well ahead of any other gauge you might make about illness, sickness, disability or for that matter, general trends in society."

Ministers are consulting on the new eligibility criteria for the disability benefit system, which will be announced in the autumn.

what do you think?

first 20 comments

Paul Anthony Croft

9:38am on 14/5/2012

I agree - they can always do seated jobs, or jobs that only need one hand! This is BRAIN DEAD. Root out the real scroungers and fakes, don't pick on disabled people. I personally know 3 or 4 "disabled" claimants who are as fit as me, but don't want work.

Score: 8

Roger W. Patrick

9:50am on 14/5/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 2

Name witheld

9:50am on 14/5/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 10

Name witheld

9:53am on 14/5/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

Chris Eaton

10:04am on 14/5/2012

.... and this from a polotical party tainted with MP expenses fraud - yes - fraud - do these people thing we have such short memories ? Fully endorse Roger W Patricks comments. I could understand this economy measure in a time when there are plenty of job opportunities to be had, but now ???? I have experiernce of one amputee with a nursing degree, now unable to fulfil this vocation due to resulting physical constraints, who in desperation could not get a job washing up at a local reaurant complex becuse tis organisation "preferred" to employ Eastern European labour ! Makes you think !!

Score: 6
1 reply

Name witheld

11:43am on 14/5/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 2

David Rankin

10:07am on 14/5/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 2

Jill Jørgensen

10:18am on 14/5/2012

As usual this has been taken out of context by the Media... I would be very sorry AND suprised if genuine claimants lost their benefits... Wouldn't it be nice if the Press had the REAL Headlines: ''BENEFIT CHEATS NOT GOING TO GET YOUR MONEY ANYMORE'' because that's what is happening... we see them every day swinging their walking sticks or Gardening, DIY or Fishing etc when they think noone is looking. Their are people who know the System & use it... we need a good sort out of these people....

Score: 7

Fleur Black

10:20am on 14/5/2012

its all the fat slobs that need targetting as the UK is sisgned up to the UN COnvention which does sttae that countries must strive to make their populations as healthy as posible.

Score: 5

Michael Morey

10:34am on 14/5/2012

tell me how people get this benefit because i have not had a penny from the state and i am a pensioner the labour government created this breed of scrounger i know people that cant work because they are to fat and if they are able to get that fat they must be getting to much money cut the money out and get them some work fat slobs greed greed greed

Score: 4

Dave Hall

10:37am on 14/5/2012

I live across the road from someone who only uses his walking stick when he goes to the doctors or into town the rest of the time he is walking around ok his wife is his carer he's got a motorbility car and he manages to be out cleaning that ok the whole family are obese and none of them have ever worked but they can still reproduce loads of kids give them food stamps instead of money then they would'nt be out spending money on mobile phones and fags

Score: 5

info

10:45am on 14/5/2012

If everyone was completely honest, we all know of at least one person whio is fiddling the benefits. Most think it is their rightful money due to them, but never the less illegal. Catch them instead of targeting the real sick or injured.

Score: 5

Mike Eaton

10:50am on 14/5/2012

"Mr Duncan Smith told the paper there had been a 30% rise in the number of claimants in recent years, with the annual cost of the benefits soon to reach £13bn" Well stop sending your young men and women off to fight an unwinable war, where daily we hear of people getting "blown up" and losing limbs! Nor only them but what a bout the people involved in traumatic limb loss due to industrial or road "accidents" - so you fit them with artificial limbs ad say OK away you go you can walk now!! The majority of these people "get on with it" but at some stage THEY WILL NEED SUPPORT especially for the traumatic mental anguish involved!

Score: 6

007 agents

11:07am on 14/5/2012

He also needs to stop telling Asylum seekers they can claim through PTSD, with all the horrors they have supposed to have seen!!!!!!!!!

Score: 4

Juls Adams

11:18am on 14/5/2012

since david cameron has got the usual conservative ideas are coming though.target them that cant fight back instead of those that are really the problem.they make me sick.there the biggest frauds.saying to someone that is a missing a limb or limbs is absolutley disgusting.labour were to easy on benifet cheats and made it to easy to claim they have gone the opposite.strange how aslyam seekers and foreigners can get benefits without trying and nothing gets said.i think reassesment is a good idea if its fair and benefit cheats should to time but this idea is taking the p@@s

Score: 3

Lee Bennett

11:19am on 14/5/2012

Not paying service men who have had limbs blown off !! jesus christ duncan smith is sick in the head,just given 10 billion quid away and now this .The tory filth have hit basement level and they are still descending ...........fast .What with hague spouting off as well just goes to show why they are twelve points behind .

Score: 8
2 replies

com196

6:05pm on 14/5/2012

well said lee 12 points i can see it being 20 points behind

Score: 2

Lee Bennett

7:35pm on 14/5/2012

agreed com196 :)

Chris Carr

11:22am on 14/5/2012

The problem lies in the assessment system, where you have a short sesion with someone who doesn't know you and just looks at a form. Fruadsters seem able to fool the system whilst those with genuine problems are denied benefits to which they should be entitled by being honest. Also, I am sure that many people amputees would love to work but firms are reluctant to take them for often nebulous "health and safety" reasons.

Score: 5

Name witheld

1:30pm on 14/5/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

john

5:47pm on 14/5/2012

Bad news for servicemen returning from Afghanistan with missing limbs. Our dear gobsmiths are really the lowest of the low.

Score: 3

Anthony Smith

6:06pm on 14/5/2012

And today's leading Tory posh burke is.........

Score: 3

Elvin Eastwood

12:12am on 15/5/2012

when are we all going to reach the opion that there just not worth knowing..and the only thing thay are good at is making a mess of things. thay send all these young lads out to fight and thay dont give a flying fig leaf about them once thay ve been blown up and damaged on the goverments behalve.

Score: 2
Advertisement