UK & World News

  • 20 September 2012, 13:52

Anti-Jihad Adverts To Run In New York Subway

The head of a group that has won its fight to run controversial adverts in New York subway stations referring to some Muslims as "savage" has told Sky News that she will fight "to the death" for the right to offend people.

Pamela Geller runs the American Freedom Defence Initiative (AFDI), which has taken out ads that read: "In any war between the civilized man and the savage, support the civilized man. Support Israel. Defeat Jihad."

The posters are due to appear in 10 New York City subway stations next week.

They were initially rejected by the New York City Metropolitan Transit Authority (MTA) because of the use of demeaning language.

But in July a Manhattan court judge ruled this was a violation of the first amendment rights of the AFDI and they should be allowed to run.

Ms Geller told Sky News that she was unconcerned the adverts might make the subway network a target for violence.

She said: "Were there similar ads on the London buses and trains on 7/7? You know there weren't.

"I will not abridge my freedoms so as not to offend savages.

"I won't take responsibility for other people being violent.

"I live in America and in America we have the first amendment."

Ms Geller, who is a prominent supporter of Israel, stressed that she was not referring to all Muslims as savages, only those who engaged in what she characterises as "Jihad".

She believes that America is under threat from some Muslims who wish to impose Sharia law on the country, and her group has launched similar campaigns before.

The release of the adverts coincides with widespread anger in parts of the Middle East over an anti-Muslim film made in the US and released on the internet.

Next week heads of state from all over the world will be converging on the city amid heightened security for the UN General Assembly.

The Washington DC MTA has deferred the placement of the controversial ads "out of concern for public safety, given current world events".

But New York MTA Transportation spokesman Aaron Donovan said: "Our hands are tied."

There had been some suggestions that the city's transit body was trying to find a way to stop the adverts appearing.

However, another spokesperson for the MTA told Sky News it appeared the ads are definitely going ahead, although he was unable to say on which day, and at which subway stations.

Ibrahim Hooper, spokesman for the Council on American Islamic Relations, told Sky News: "Our basic position is that the first amendment means that everyone is free to be a bigot or even an idiot like Pamela Geller.

"We wish she wasn't provoking and inciting hatred, but in America that's her right.

"We encourage Muslims to exercise the same right to publicly denounce such adverts.

"The real danger is the spread of hatred in our society, which can lead to attacks on innocent people."

what do you think?

15 comments

Luke Grailey

2:49am on 20/9/2012

Sometimes, just because you have the right to do or say something, it doesnt mean you should. Freedoms should be used responsibly.

Score: 12
1 reply

jeni sperber

12:11pm on 20/9/2012

Well said

Chris Price

3:26am on 20/9/2012

"The real danger is the spread of hatred in our society, which can lead to attacks on innocent people" learn to rise above it then, prove that Islam is the religion of peace that Muslims claim it to be. This is yet another case of some idiot trying to get a reaction and say look "I told you they were all savages"

Score: 15

Windows Live User

5:10am on 20/9/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 11
1 reply

Name witheld

8:13am on 20/9/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

Neil Foster

6:27am on 20/9/2012

Can't say anything to offend these ppl ?

Score: 10

Name witheld

6:30am on 20/9/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Name witheld

7:35am on 20/9/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 8

jeni sperber

7:38am on 20/9/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

blue side

8:08am on 20/9/2012

Freedom brings responsibility certainly there is a right to critisise Islam without the reaction we have been witnessing which in itself only reinforces the claims made against Islam. However that said this act is not intended to promote debate or inform its sole purpose is to incite a reaction in exactly the same way that those Islamic masters have stirred up their own. She will have blood on her hands just the same as the Islamic controllers have - I am amazed the US courts have not acted.

Score: 8

Rob Shaw

8:19am on 20/9/2012

Well this sin't going to cause any problems....... Just provoking terrorism if anything

Score: 10

TIM x

8:56am on 20/9/2012

I support Israel 100%. But I do not believe all Muslims are savages.

Score: 11

john

9:34am on 20/9/2012

A prominent supporter of Israel eh? what a surprise, not.

Score: 9

ali baba

9:41am on 20/9/2012

Does this stupid woman know that the first terrorist attack in Israel was by a Jew against the British. Does that make all Jews savages?. I hate all fanatics but let's be clear about something, at the core of any terrorism there usually is a reasoning that there is some form of occupation or bullying.

Score: 15
1 reply

Michael Mcardle

4:08pm on 20/9/2012

oh baba still trying to lay the blame for all the cowardly terrorist attacks firmly at the door of western cultures. you sad man.by the way you still enjoying all the benefits of living in a western country.ye of little shame ha ha

Score: 3

Prince Shaz

9:48am on 20/9/2012

You gota be flipping kidding me!!! Absolute idiot. Enough said.

Score: 12

ali baba

9:49am on 20/9/2012

"Political power grows out of the barrel of a gun". funny when Jews and Christians use guns its ok.

Score: 18
3 replies

Name witheld

12:31pm on 20/9/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

Michael Mcardle

4:11pm on 20/9/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 2

ali baba

4:56pm on 20/9/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

speller007

4:17pm on 21/9/2012

perhaps this is the start of a backlash against extremist muslims using Islam as the escape goat for all there violent activities. stating the violence is justified because there interpretation of the holy koran says so? i feel they are disrespecting there own faith and giving the rest of the non muslim world an horrendous impression of the religion. shame on them!

Advertisement