UK & World News

  • 1 February 2013, 1:21

Bali: Brit's Death Penalty Funding Battle Lost

A British grandmother has lost a legal battle over the UK Government's refusal to fund her appeal against a death sentence imposed by an Indonesian court for drug smuggling.

Two judges in London refused to declare unlawful a Foreign and Commonwealth Office decision not to pay for "an adequate lawyer" to represent Lindsay Sandiford, 56, from Cheltenham, Gloucestershire.

Mrs Justice Gloster, sitting with Mrs Justice Nicola Davies, said the court understood "the deep concerns of Mrs Sandiford and her family about Mrs Sandiford's predicament" but her case must be dismissed for reasons to be given on Monday next week.

Sandiford, originally from Redcar, Teesside, was given the death penalty by a court in Bali last week for taking 10.6lb of cocaine on to the island.

The sentence would see her shot by a firing squad.

She was accused by the court of damaging the image of Bali and received the sentence despite prosecutors asking only for a 15-year jail term.

The High Court was told that a notice of appeal was filed with Indonesian officials earlier this week and she was given a 14-day deadline to file grounds of appeal.

Aidan O'Neill QC said Sandiford was urgently in need of funding because she is without legal assistance and her family have exhausted all of their available resources.

what do you think?

7 comments

shaun spencer

6:07pm on 31/1/2013

I really dont understand this.even if she was completely guilty id have expected the uk goverment to help, even if it meant they could put a claim on her property.must be more to this than meets the eye, which i guess we will find out monday.but i cant see what reason is going to change my mind.

Score: 7
5 replies

brian foster

6:51pm on 31/1/2013

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 8

shaun spencer

8:05pm on 31/1/2013

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

suziestar17

9:35pm on 31/1/2013

Shaun, I may well be wrong but I am guessing the reason for her not gaining help is because she had moved out of this country for live in India 5 years ago. It is not a case of a Brit going on holiday. She emigrated. I have seen the stories of her children being threatened e.t.c but I cannot understand how this can be used as an excuse when she was happy enough to co-operate as soon as she was caught. Surely she put her children at risk then? It doesn't make sense to me for sure.

Score: 1

shaun spencer

10:50pm on 31/1/2013

Well if her children were being threatened she proberly would know the best way out.but if there were threats and blackmail and coersion i then dont think she should be killed.i wonder if she had any past history of doing this.yes maybe shes done this before that would be a reason for the uk to withdraw money.

Score: 1

suziestar17

11:27pm on 31/1/2013

I think it is standard to not pay out if no longer living here. Has she done this before? Seen story that she previously was hash courier but anyone's guess if stories are true.

Score: 1

shirley sutton

6:11pm on 31/1/2013

She broke their laws why should we pay for get appeal - shouldn't have done it then she wouldn't be in that situation all her own doing

Score: 18
2 replies

shaun spencer

7:48pm on 31/1/2013

Have i missed something here, i thought they were claiming that she had been coerced into doing this by drug traffickers.and that she was going to appeal against her death sentence.

Score: 4

shirley sutton

9:22pm on 31/1/2013

I'm sorry but she chose to move to Bali she broke the law and she had her trial In the country she chose to live in and break the law in why should we pay for her appeals etc

Score: 4

sunshine

6:35pm on 31/1/2013

The right decision - we should not be helping convicted drug dealers especially in foreign lands

Score: 13

Londliveengland 66

7:03pm on 31/1/2013

We call these countries like this uncivilised etc but I wish this country had the same punishments, I would even pay a bit more tax if druggies and the like went to the gallows

Score: 10
1 reply

TIM x

8:14pm on 31/1/2013

You have my sympathies but in UK the media circus makes the death penalty unworkable. It would be horrific if an innocent person was hanged. The media crucified Jo Yates landlord even though he was completely innocent. He won damages but media hype over a person on trial could influence a jury to convict

Score: 5

Mike Anon

7:41pm on 31/1/2013

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 5

TIM x

8:18pm on 31/1/2013

She has a right to legal representation this isn't a shop lifting case it's her life.

Score: 7
2 replies

shirley sutton

8:57pm on 31/1/2013

She should have thought of that beforehand then

Score: 4

shaun spencer

9:16pm on 31/1/2013

I keep asking but wasnt she claiming that she had been blackmailed and coersed to smuggle in the drugs.or has this been found to be untrue.

Score: 2

stephen

10:17pm on 31/1/2013

the fascist are on here tonight

Score: 5
Advertisement