UK & World News

  • 14 December 2012, 16:00

MPs' Expenses: Moran Given Supervision Order

Former Labour MP Margaret Moran is so mentally ill she would have to be restrained in order to leave her house, a court heard as she was sentenced for fiddling her expenses.

Moran, 57, who represented Luton South for 13 years, received more than £53,000 from the taxpayer as a result of the fraud.

She claimed nearly her entire annual allowance in one bogus expense entry and forged invoices for more than £20,000 for non-existent goods and services.

The disgraced former MP's claims were the largest amount uncovered in the wake of the MPs' expenses scandal, but she could not be convicted after a judge ruled she was unfit to stand trial for mental health reasons.

She was sentenced at Southwark Crown Court to a two-year supervision and treatment order, to be supervised by Southampton City Council.

Moran was not present in court to hear Mr Justice Saunders make the ruling.

However, her psychiatrist, Dr Simon Kelly, from the Priory Hospital in Southampton, said he last saw her on Tuesday and described her as "very distressed, very agitated" and "severely ill".

He added: "She's living a restricted lifestyle, she's not answered the telephone at home for approximately three years, she goes out very occasionally, to a local supermarket for 30 minutes."

Moran found a newspaper report in November that she had been spotted at a pub in London "deeply distressing", Dr Kelly said.

Asked how she would have reacted if she had to come to court, the psychiatrist said: "She is so sensitised to publicity, this would have been the most difficult place for her to come.

"I wonder physically whether it would be possible to get her here.

"I don't know whether it would be physically possible to remove her from her home without restraining her."

Sentencing Moran to the supervision order, Mr Justice Saunders told the court he expected there would be a feeling that she had "got away with it"

He said: "All the evidence in the case was that she was unfit to plead. If I had reached any other conclusion my decision would have been perverse and would inevitably have been successfully appealed."

The judge said the order would be under the supervision of a mental health social worker and Moran would continue treatment with Dr Kelly.

what do you think?

first 20 comments

john

10:00am on 14/12/2012

Mrs Josephine Bloggs in Newcastle just got sent down for fiddling 40 thousand pounds in housing benefit, one law for them, one law for us.

Score: 23

Brian Holmes

10:11am on 14/12/2012

She got away with it.

Score: 21

Mike Anon

10:12am on 14/12/2012

This 'woman' fraudulently claims £53,000 & is given a two year "supervision & treatment order". If any member of the public did this they would be languishing behind bars at Her Majesty's pleasure for a considerable length of time. The term 'them & us' springs to mind!

Score: 24

Gordon Wright

10:20am on 14/12/2012

She will no doubt make a speedy "recovery" now...................

Score: 19

Ben Ralph

10:21am on 14/12/2012

Anyone else reckon she will miraculously recover in 8-12 months?

Score: 20
2 replies

John Mechelen

11:04am on 14/12/2012

4 to 8 weeks more likely.They earn nice money+ perks,and they still fiddle and they have the nerve to call themselves the right hon,right crook more like it.

Score: 13

davenlesley

6:52pm on 14/12/2012

Ben. It would be harder to find someone who didn't

Score: 8

Russell6730

10:31am on 14/12/2012

She should have been given a prison order.

Score: 25
2 replies

John Mechelen

10:45am on 14/12/2012

10 yrs at least and hard labour.

Score: 8

davenlesley

6:51pm on 14/12/2012

Lads. Judges = establishment, MP's = establishment. The establishment looks after its own, simples

Score: 10

Jasmin Louise

10:58am on 14/12/2012

Mental health issues only occur when they're caught!

Score: 23
4 replies

davenlesley

6:49pm on 14/12/2012

Jasmin. Too true. She had enough mental agility to milk the corrupt system and put in place all the scams but ther minute she gets caught we are told she is raving. Yeah right

Score: 11

Jasmin Louise

7:24pm on 14/12/2012

Spot on! What's your name? Sorry, occupational hazard lol... Are you better known as Dave Harrison?

Score: 9

davenlesley

8:19pm on 14/12/2012

Jasmin. Yes it is me. They deleted the last reply

Score: 8

GillieLouise

11:46am on 15/12/2012

Absolutely correct Jasmine... you have hit the nail right on the head.

Score: 10

michael crane

11:01am on 14/12/2012

She should have been sent down, not only did she steal and commit fraud, she stole from every taxpayer in the land.

Score: 24

joelle cooke

11:10am on 14/12/2012

the whole Establishment,stinks!!

Score: 24

Tony Price

11:14am on 14/12/2012

Can we have our money back now then. If it was you or me and it was income tax or tax credits they would be on us like a shot!

Score: 18

Gordon Wright

11:18am on 14/12/2012

There are now so many thieves in Parliament, I believe they have to say "Open Sesame" to gain entry..................

Score: 20

peter

11:22am on 14/12/2012

CRIME CERTAINLY DOES PAY.

Score: 23

Name witheld

12:17pm on 14/12/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

teresa foster

1:15pm on 14/12/2012

another thief dressed as a MP how many more about

Score: 19
1 reply

davenlesley

6:46pm on 14/12/2012

Teresa. Probably close on 630 I would think.

Score: 15

wickhampatrick

1:52pm on 14/12/2012

How ever mentally ill they say, she's still a crook. So when she is deemed to be well again send her to prison for at least ten years for stealing from the British taxpayers. MP's we are supposed to trust, but we can't that's a sign of the times. If anyone in future wants to be an MP check their record, credit checks, everything we possibly can and put them under a microscope for the first two years at least to ensure that they don't steal from us!

Score: 13
2 replies

Name witheld

3:17pm on 14/12/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

Brian Holmes

9:26pm on 14/12/2012

I don't think that would work. As soon as they taste power it corrupts them. We need real deterrants especially for people in public office.

Score: 8

davenlesley

6:46pm on 14/12/2012

Mr Justice Saunders said there would be a feeling that she had "got away with it" Absolutely right M'Lud .You did let her get away with it. Whatever happened to seizing her assetts under the proceeds of crime act??

Score: 17
3 replies

Gordon Wright

7:10pm on 14/12/2012

An excellent question..............

Score: 9

GillieLouise

11:45am on 15/12/2012

Quite right Dave..... I wonder what my window cleaner would get for working Tax free..... Jail no doubt.?

Score: 8

GillieLouise

12:20pm on 15/12/2012

You cant hide Dave Harrison....We know who you are xxxx

Score: 7

Gordon Wright

7:20pm on 14/12/2012

How can she be living a "restricted lifestyle" with £53,000 of nicked taxpayers cash stuffed under her mattress????

Score: 15
3 replies

GillieLouise

12:04pm on 15/12/2012

Quite right Gordon.... makes me want to turn to crime!!

Score: 9

Gordon Wright

12:09pm on 15/12/2012

Don't do it Gillie, they send ordinary people like us to jail. This sort of treatment applies only to the "Great and the Good" .................

Score: 8

GillieLouise

12:19pm on 15/12/2012

Recover the money eh Gordon, we can live in hope?

Score: 11

john

7:25pm on 14/12/2012

In todays local Newcastle Upon Tyne newspaper: woman told that she will celebrate Christmas in jail by judge for commiting benefit fraud, her defense team pleaded mental health issues, it didn't cut any ice with the judge. She should have been an MP, the law doesn't seem to apply to them.

Score: 15
1 reply

davenlesley

11:19am on 15/12/2012

John. She should have checked herself into St Nicks and played the I a nutter card like this theiving cow. Priory clinic eh, wonder where she got the money from

Score: 8

GillieLouise

12:04pm on 15/12/2012

I have suffered from chronic depressing since childhood.... could someone please suggest what I could get away with??? This is British justice at its most comical....... Our tax payers money is in this criminal woman's bank account and she walks free.

Score: 11
1 reply

Gordon Wright

12:12pm on 15/12/2012

Hello again Gillie, Better news in this morning's papers, apparently there may be moves afoot to recover the cash. I certainly hope so...................

Score: 10

Phil A

12:27pm on 15/12/2012

I look forward to her miraculous recovery over the next couple of weeks.

Score: 15
Advertisement