UK & World News

  • 9 November 2012, 5:41

Cameron Hits Out At 'Trial By Twitter'

Number 10 has warned against a "trial by Twitter" over sexual abuse claims after David Cameron was handed a list of suspects on live television.

The Prime Minister's spokesman said in a briefing: "We should not have a trial by Twitter. People should not be throwing about unsubstantiated allegations."

He added: "There are lots of accusations flying round and many accusations on the internet. We need to be very careful.

"If there are allegations, they need to be looked at properly in the right way by the relevant authorities. People need to be cautious of the fact that naming names could have implications for future criminal prosecutions."

The fresh warning followed Mr Cameron expressing fears about a "witch hunt" of gay people after he was questioned about the claims during an interview.

He was given a list of suspected paedophiles by Phillip Schofield when he appeared on ITV's This Morning, where he was appearing to talk about dementia.

Schofield, who said he had found the names on a quick trawl of the internet, came under fire after accidentally exposing the list on camera as it was handed to the PM.

Mr Cameron did not look at it and put it on the table, before raising concerns about internet speculation over who might be embroiled in historic cases.

"There is a danger if we are not careful that this can turn into a sort of witch hunt, particularly about people who are gay, and I'm worried about the sort of thing you are doing right now, taking a list of names off the internet," he told Schofield.

"If anyone has any information about anyone who's a paedophile, no matter how high up in society they are, that is what the police are for."

He added: "I've heard all sorts of names bandied around and what then tends to happen is everyone sits around and speculates about people, some of whom are alive, some of whom are dead."

Mr Cameron insisted the Government was moving quickly to investigate new claims, which include allegations that a senior Conservative from the Thatcher era was involved in abuse in North Wales.

One of the alleged victims in that case, Steve Messham, has claimed he was regularly taken to a hotel and sold for sex - including to the politician.

The Prime Minister described the allegations as "extremely serious" and pointed out the Government had this week launched an inquiry into the Welsh care home scandal.

There are now a series of different investigations into historic allegations, with two into the Welsh case and others sparked by the Jimmy Savile scandal.

The Prime Minister defended the move not to set up a single inquiry to look at all the claims, insisting this would not necessarily be quicker.

"The idea that if you had one mega-inquiry that you would speed everything up, I'm not sure is true," he said.

"I don't rule out taking further steps. I want the Government to be absolutely on top of this, I don't want anything to be covered up, I don't want any information to be held back. If there are more things we have to do, we will do them.

"But we always have to remember it's very easy for governments just to stand up and say, 'Here's a new inquiry.' What we've got to do is get to the truth as fast as we possibly can."

Conservative MP Stuart Andrew, who was a councillor in Wrexham at the time of the original inquiry in the 1990s into the Welsh abuse, accused Schofield of mounting a "very cheap stunt".

Mr Andrew said: "It is not acceptable to take a cheap shot on something that is so fiercely sensitive. Anybody who has got any allegations to make must make them to the police, so they can be properly investigated."

Schofield later said in a statement: "If any viewer was able to identify anyone listed, I would like to apologise and stress that was never my intention.

"I was not accusing anyone of anything and it is essential that it is understood that I would never be part of any kind of witch hunt.

"Unfortunately, there may have been a misjudged camera angle for a split second as I showed the Prime Minister some information I had obtained from the internet.

"I asked for his reaction to give him the opportunity to make a point which he very clearly made about the dangers of any witch hunt."

Update:

Hello, regular commenting on Orange News and Sport pages closes on Thursday 30 May 2013. We will continue to provide a commenting facility on major news and sport events on orangeworld.co.uk. Contact us via http://oran.ge/OWfeedback if you have any further questions. Thanks.

what do you think?

first 20 comments

Russell6730

2:53pm on 8/11/2012

Camerons liberal views on this subject are way out of step with about 95% of the people of this nation as he will soon discover to his cost.

Score: 25
1 reply

Malcolm Charlesworth

3:20pm on 8/11/2012

If 95% of the population brand someone a "pedalfile" does that make it true? We are in danger of recreating a role of witchfinder general looking for "pedalfiles". Once named and shamed they are guilty unless they can prove otherwise. (Someone remind me, did they prove innocence by drowning if submerged in water? What I do remember of my reading of the history of the time was that the accused were set an impossible task to prove their innocence.) History seems to be repeating itself.

Score: 23

Peter Coates

2:53pm on 8/11/2012

Good old ditherer.

Score: 21

mark townend

3:02pm on 8/11/2012

I see a lot of suicides ahead

Score: 13

john

3:21pm on 8/11/2012

Oh, it's a witch hunt now is it? Is that because the spotlight has turned on child abusers in the upper echelons of society? Is Cameron rattled because a conservative ex-cabinet minister have been accused of vile abuse of children.

Score: 39
3 replies

Edgar Beckett

3:40pm on 8/11/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Grant Berry

4:41pm on 8/11/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

Lorgar Aurelian

4:42pm on 8/11/2012

Ridiculous.

Score: 14

J R

3:32pm on 8/11/2012

John - how would you like to be falsely accused of such things ? You would never be able to shake it off. Cameron is right - this is a matter for the police. End of.

Score: 34
2 replies

Andrea Hill

4:23pm on 8/11/2012

Quite right.!!

Score: 20

gengisken1227

5:27pm on 8/11/2012

Agreed, just because names are on the internet, doesn't make them true. I mean it may be, but everyone is innocent until proved guilty or should be.

Score: 13

simon williams

3:37pm on 8/11/2012

This man makes my skin crawl every time i see him.

Score: 23
1 reply

Nigel L

4:10pm on 8/11/2012

Agree Schofield has that effect on me to

Score: 23

Julia Feeley

3:55pm on 8/11/2012

Somebody told me recently they could tell if a person was a paedophile just by looking at them - what a remarkable talent she has! Years ago when I was on jury service one of the other jurors said to the rest of the group (whilst we considered the evidence) "if the police arrested him, he must have done it!" and that was that as far as he was concerned! The defendant was actually found not guilty. We nicknamed the juror "Hang 'em High" after that!

Score: 19

david

4:12pm on 8/11/2012

this is true,,1 paper no names but its big in scotland ,,printed a story of a girl who met J.S,, and wrote he tryed to sexually feel her up.she was never contacted by the paper they are just going through shows and finding names of people who were on the show and writing what they want,,

Score: 12
1 reply

jimmyjedi1979

4:45pm on 8/11/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Nigel L

4:12pm on 8/11/2012

Very cheap trick by Schofield ITV should know better

Score: 31
2 replies

Andrea Hill

4:23pm on 8/11/2012

Yes shocked at scohfield to be honest. Cheap tactic there.

Score: 19

Grant Berry

4:40pm on 8/11/2012

Schofield made his self look childish

Score: 19

Grant Berry

4:39pm on 8/11/2012

Well said Mr Cameron, we have a proper laws in place for this. Some people who disagree are the offspring of those sheeple who used to turn up at public hangings for the kick of it.

Score: 35
1 reply

jimmyjedi1979

4:44pm on 8/11/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

IRONSTINE

4:40pm on 8/11/2012

Mr Cameron has not blamed previous governments for cover ups hillsborough, saville, miners strike, care home child abuse, and why is he involving happy people? are we to believe he had no idea the what the notw was up to when his closest of friend's are in hot water.

Score: 22

jimmyjedi1979

4:44pm on 8/11/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

jimmyjedi1979

4:51pm on 8/11/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

jimmyjedi1979

4:55pm on 8/11/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Mike

5:05pm on 8/11/2012

Why did Cameron link paedophiles with gays? Surely this is much too sweeping a judgement.

Score: 16

leslie lee

5:09pm on 8/11/2012

makes you laaaarf this . dave old boy it is almost a prerequisite that to be in either the music business or westminster you need either to be a hom osexual or paedophile ............. its par for the course sweetie !

Score: 25

shirley sutton

5:35pm on 8/11/2012

It's ok for everybody else but not for Tory members who've done wrong - not complained about jimmy saville etc but protecting their own now

Score: 22

Lorgar Aurelian

6:00pm on 8/11/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Lorgar Aurelian

6:26pm on 8/11/2012

Ok Orange, i'll try rephrasing it - I refer you all to the case of a mob that turned up at a blokes house baying for his blood... because he was a paediatrician. Can't add anymore, it's forbidden it seems.

Score: 10

movvi

6:31pm on 8/11/2012

Has Philip Schofield gone mad? He seems to be making the headlines for doing silly things a bit lately. I wonder how many of us - indeed including him - would be horrified to find ourselves on such a list? All sorts of insults fly about online and so it would probably be very easy to come across all manner of false accusations about many. I think David Cameron was right and party preferences are irrelevant here; he seems to be discouraging mudslinging which has got to be a good thing! Does anyone remember that wiry-haired former teacher accused of and arrested for murder because some thought he was "weird"?

Score: 21
Advertisement