Financial News

  • 16 January 2012, 19:40

French Pledge Further Reforms After Downgrade

The French prime minister, Francois Fillon, has said the loss of France's AAA credit rating had been "expected" but warned it should not be "dramatised".

France is the largest and most significant of nine eurozone members to have their credit ratings downgraded by the agency, Standard & Poor's (S&P) on Friday.

Mr Fillon pledged to make further budgetary adjustments if necessary but said that his government supported the efforts of President Nicolas Sarkozy, who is facing re-election later this year.

He said: "The president and I don't have to wait for what a credit agency decides to know what we have to do - reduce our deficits, improve our competitiveness and give the eurozone the leadership it lacks.

"We expected this decision, even though we consider it ill-timed given the efforts the eurozone is making - something investors are already recognising."

But he said that the decision changed nothing about France's growth prospects: "There is no objective reason today that allows us to revise growth."

France, which along with Austria is now rated at AA+, was also given a "negative outlook" by S&P which means there is a one-in-three chance of a further downgrade within the next year.

The decision casts fresh doubts over the effectiveness of the eurozone's bailout fund, the EFSF, whose ability to raise money to provide a safety net for troubled member states will be hampered by the downgrade of France, its second largest underwriter.

Italy, Spain and Portugal which have been at the centre of recent debt crisis turmoil each lost two points on the ratings scale.

Malta, Slovakia, Slovenia and Cyprus were also downgraded but Germany, the Netherlands, Luxembourg and Finland escaped with their AAA ratings intact.

Announcing its decision, S&P said: "The downgrade reflects our opinion of the impact of deepening political, financial, and monetary problems within the eurozone."

It also said European politicians had failed to make significant progress to end the crisis despite their planned "Fiscal Compact" - a treaty between 26 EU members that will set strict new limits on government spending and borrowing which British Prime Minister David Cameron has refused to join.

"The outcomes from the EU summit on December 9, 2011, and subsequent statements from policymakers lead us to believe that the agreement reached has not produced a breakthrough of sufficient size and scope to fully address the eurozone's financial problems," S&P said.

The European Commissioner for the Internal Market, Michel Barnier said: "I am surprised at the moment chosen by the Standard and Poor's agency, and fundamentally of its evaluation which does not take into account recent progress."

The Cypriot government, whose rating was reduced to the "junk status" level of BB+, accused the ratings agency of high-handed behaviour that ignored the island's attempts to consolidate its finances.

Finance minister Kikis Kazamias said: "This decision can justifiably be considered arbitrary and unsubstantiated."

In August, S&P stripped the US of its AAA credit rating for the first time in its history because the deficit reduction plan passed by Congress did not go far enough to stabilise the country's debt situation.

The UK has so far clung on to its top rating but a recent report by rating agency Moody's said the eurozone debt crisis had increased the risk of a downgrade.

what do you think?

13 comments

Name witheld

12:45pm on 14/1/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 6
5 replies

chris

5:33pm on 14/1/2012

Silly man.What has that got to do with the stock market get your facts right ,

Score: 3

Grant Berry

11:31am on 15/1/2012

what a fool, & a negative one to boot

Score: 2

Gordon Berry

3:01pm on 15/1/2012

When people as ill informed as you are make such statements I feel you should excuse youself from voting in future

Score: 2

Name witheld

6:50pm on 15/1/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

David Wragg

10:16am on 16/1/2012

There is a difference between stock market speculation and currency speculation, but in this case it is neither, simply a calculation that the French are not running their economy as well as they would like us to believe.

Score: 1

Windows Live User

12:57pm on 14/1/2012

& Scotland are talking about joining if they decide to split from the UK Salmond needs to have his head looked at. Best to stick with the £GBP for the forseeable future

Score: 3
2 replies

james

2:40pm on 14/1/2012

Scotland can go it alone but not keep the £ Stirling. Their new coin will be the Porridge.

Score: 2

Name witheld

3:17pm on 14/1/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

gengisken1227

2:26pm on 14/1/2012

Merkosy hold EU meetings for two years and do nothing, agree on nothing except to try to screw Britain (again) Poetic justice; who said there wasn't a god !

Score: 10
1 reply

Grant Berry

11:32am on 15/1/2012

spot on

Score: 2

Name witheld

3:16pm on 14/1/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Name witheld

5:59pm on 14/1/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 5
2 replies

Roger Rushkin

3:54pm on 16/1/2012

What a silly thing to write

Score: 1

chris

10:45pm on 16/1/2012

Yes, we should really be closer to France, possibly, than anyone else. If we could just get on and enjoy some peace and prosperity. I don't mean share the Euro woes.

Mike McDonough

6:32pm on 14/1/2012

The only people to gain from this will be currency speculators with the Euro losing ground.

Name witheld

7:26pm on 14/1/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 2

jjg118

10:09am on 15/1/2012

another failure for the french. even if we loose AAA now atleast the french n us went first. the us gov sait a fer weeks age that no one us AAA anymore... we are hahaha

Score: 1

Name witheld

11:38am on 15/1/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 2

gengisken1227

12:44pm on 15/1/2012

An EU (unelected) commissioner Michel Banier is "surprised at the moment chosen by Standard & Poors" ? Errrr No Mr Barnier, several dodgy EZ countries need 200 billion in the next three months from investors to keep themselves afloat. Shouldn't investors, be fully informed as to the correct credit status of these soverign nation seeking mega loans.

Score: 3

David Wragg

10:18am on 16/1/2012

Sarkozy and Merkel have held numerous meetings but actually done nothing! The pre-Christmas agreement was about the future rules for the Eurozone, and did nothing to address the immediate problems of Greece, etc, and in any case, the existing rules were ignored so what hope is there that it will be different in future?

Mike Webster

12:42pm on 16/1/2012

When you realise that France has more 'Quangos' than UK run by unelected appointees and some 30% of their workforce is employed directly or indirectly by Government, who are not allowed to work more than 35 hours a week and can retire as early as 55 years on very generous pensions, you can see why their economy is in a mess. Cameron has at least had the guts to attempt to reform our 'fat-cat' state sector, whereas Sarkozy dare not as there is an election in 2012. All he is doing is talking a good talk to delay any reforms until after the election!

Score: 1
1 reply

chris

10:50pm on 16/1/2012

Unions in France are far to organised and powerfull to allow any such reforms in their public sector pay any time soon. The only hope is that factory output/exports can grow enough to sustain it.

Roger Rushkin

3:53pm on 16/1/2012

These are the same ratings Agencies that gave AAA to all the banks that were creating toxic loans in the US that eventually caused the international collapse. This is entirely political. The agencies are based in the US. Both the US and the UK have larger defecits and public debts than France. By constantly downgrading the Eurozone it 'encourages' investors to invest in the US - despite the fact that the US is the most indebted country ion the world.

Score: 1
1 reply

chris

10:59pm on 16/1/2012

But if the eurozone controlled the ratings agencies what mechanism would be used to deter euro countries on a spending spree like Greece? surely the UK, and certainly the US, still have some ability to cut Public costs and trade their way out of this mess? something the likes of greece can't do?

Advertisement