UK & World News

  • 18 September 2012, 17:28

Death Row Man: 'I'm Too Fat To Be Executed'

A death row inmate who weighs at least 34 stone says he is too fat to be executed.

Ronald Post, who shot and killed a hotel clerk in northern Ohio almost 30 years ago, said his weight could lead to a "torturous and lingering death".

Ohio executes inmates with a single dose of pentobarbital, usually injected through the arms.

Court documents submitted by his lawyers said vein access, scar tissue, and other medical problems raise the likelihood that his executioners would encounter severe problems.

It is also claimed he is so big that the execution gurney might not hold him.

"Indeed, given his unique physical and medical condition there is a substantial risk that any attempt to execute him will result in serious physical and psychological pain to him, as well as an execution involving a torturous and lingering death," court papers said.

He has tried losing weight, but knee and back problems have made it difficult to exercise, his lawyers wrote.

His request for gastric bypass surgery has been denied, he has been encouraged not to walk because he is at risk of falling, and severe depression has contributed to his inability to limit how much he eats, his legal team added.

Post, 53, is scheduled to die on January 16 for the 1983 shooting death of Helen Vantz in the town of Elyria.

A spokeswoman for the state's prisons department declined to comment.

Inmates' weight has come up previously in death penalty cases in Ohio and elsewhere.

In 2008, federal courts rejected arguments by 19-stone condemned double-killer Richard Cooey that he was too obese to die by injection.

His lawyers argued that prison food and limited opportunities to exercise contributed to a weight problem that would make it difficult for the execution team to find a suitable vein.

He was executed later that year.

what do you think?

first 20 comments

Tom Lee

8:37am on 18/9/2012

kill him end of loser....

Score: 19

Michael Dynes

9:01am on 18/9/2012

He was quite brave when he was murdering a woman. He's not so brave now is he?

Score: 22
1 reply

Julie Crumpton

8:50am on 19/9/2012

...they never are, Michael!

Score: 4

Emma Allum

9:06am on 18/9/2012

So give him a double

Score: 20
2 replies

Jasmin Louise

9:42am on 18/9/2012

Hahaha good one :)

Score: 11

Julie Crumpton

8:50am on 19/9/2012

Well, you make a good point Emma, do they not calculate how much is injected by weight anyway?

Score: 4

Tim Wells

9:11am on 18/9/2012

Should get death by cheesecake

Score: 10
1 reply

eastonandrea

2:56pm on 18/9/2012

LOL :-)

Score: 5

Emma Scott

9:20am on 18/9/2012

What about the psychological pain felt by the family of the lady he killed? He didn't care about that when he shot an innocent person so why should anybody care about the feelings of a guilty man?

Score: 17

Katie Smith

9:31am on 18/9/2012

How is he this weight when he's on death row? am I being a bit stupid? why can't they put him on a diet so he loses the weight? he's locked up isn't he? eat what's being put in front of you or don't eat at all! what's he being given? junk food or something? are they going out to get takeaways for him, if it was in this country then I could probably understand it but I didn't think it was all about the human rights of the criminal in the usa!.

Score: 19
1 reply

Vanessa Lake

2:47pm on 18/9/2012

Absolutely! This is a bloody joke.

Score: 13

Laurence Oleiski

9:59am on 18/9/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Steve Barker

10:17am on 18/9/2012

Stop feeding him.....simple.

Score: 15
2 replies

Jasmin Louise

10:36am on 18/9/2012

Sreve, he's already been executed! Good eh? :)

Score: 7

Julie Crumpton

8:48am on 19/9/2012

...so why have you been voted down, jasmine? Pathetic!

Score: 1

Rob Shaw

10:23am on 18/9/2012

So what if it is going to cause severe pain! At the end of the day, he's being put to DEATH for murdering someone. Very convenient that depression and all these things are preventing him from loosing weight to evetually be killed. It should in no way be peaceful experience for him. Let him suffer, fat greedy waste of space

Score: 21

Rob Hicks

11:02am on 18/9/2012

shoot him then

Score: 17
1 reply

t.bulgin

12:21pm on 18/9/2012

Yes, in the head, several times.

Score: 10

eastonandrea

11:11am on 18/9/2012

I'm alittle confused at end of story it says "He was ex*cuted later that year", who was the 34 stone Ronald Post or the 19 stone Richard Cooney? As i think it states that Ronald is to be ex*cuted 16 Januaury. If he is still to be ex*cuted then they have 4 months in which to give him a crash diet to lower his weight to a reasonable size.

Score: 6
2 replies

Jasmin Louise

12:14pm on 18/9/2012

Hi Andrea, I was having a blonde moment earlier lol. It's Post scheduled to be executed in January. Hope he over-eats at Christmas and has a heart attack!..........

Score: 9

eastonandrea

3:02pm on 18/9/2012

LOL Jasmin, save the expense of the lethal injection. Maybe stick him in boot camp and see how he can handle that, heart attack waiting to happen.

Score: 8

andy may

11:51am on 18/9/2012

so what's his point? yes, i understand his claim that he may suffer a "torturous and lingering" death. so what, did the gluton show the same consideration when he killed an innocent hotel clerk?

Score: 16
2 replies

MichaelStinton

8:52pm on 18/9/2012

Inhumane and before you say it two wrongs will not make it right.

Score: 11

Julie Crumpton

8:47am on 19/9/2012

No...they don't, but don't you think he deserves to die?

Score: 6

Rob Shaw

1:12pm on 18/9/2012

Iv'e noticed someone has a problem with everyone about making him have the injections anyway, by down voting everyone's comments. Just wonder if they would like to come forward and have their say in his defence? Instead of hiding

Score: 13
4 replies

Rob Shaw

2:59pm on 18/9/2012

.......Thought so

Score: 11

Julie Crumpton

3:51pm on 18/9/2012

People won't, aj....it annoys me too! So people are allowed to disagree,....but say WHY!!!

Score: 11

Jasmin Louise

4:43pm on 18/9/2012

A Jowett. Just ignore the voting down! They troll the site voting users down on anything from condolence messages to criminals receiving life sentences! Numpties Haha

Score: 11

Julie Crumpton

8:46am on 19/9/2012

But why? Jasmine? If you feel strongly and disagree...fine! But what would be the point? I personally ignore it, but would like to hear why sometimes?

Score: 4

Ev Beard

3:44pm on 18/9/2012

Does he not realise we would all prefer if he did have a slow lingering death, so he could reflect on his crime.

Score: 17
1 reply

El Bubsio

3:36am on 19/9/2012

I have no desire to see that thanks. I guess I don't have the same bloodlust fuelled need for revenge that some people do.

Score: 10

Adj Jackson

4:00pm on 18/9/2012

Well if he's to fat to be executed then other means need to be found!!!! Errrrrrrrmmm errrrmmmm oh yes an Elephant Gun shuold do the trick

Score: 14
1 reply

Julie Crumpton

8:42am on 19/9/2012

Yep! That should do it!

Score: 3

TIM x

4:41pm on 18/9/2012

Not too fat to take an innocent life though were you?

Score: 13

Name witheld

6:04am on 19/9/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Allan Evans

6:57am on 19/9/2012

"Ronald Post, who shot and killed a hotel clerk in northern Ohio almost 30 years ago, said his weight could lead to a "torturous and lingering death". And....your point?

Score: 4

Bryan Stocker

8:52am on 19/9/2012

What is more bizzare than his lame excuse for non-execution is that he's being executed for a crime he commited when he was 23. I understand there needs to be time for the appeal process, but why keep him in prison for 30 years then execute him? Also, time moves on and so do attitudes and standards, if he committed the same crime today would he get the same sentence? If not then thats even worse.

Score: 5

Tracey Walker

8:55am on 19/9/2012

I hope the belief that he will die a tortuous by injection is absolutely 100% true but the idea of watching him fry in an electric chair sounds fascinating either way a murdering piece of dirt leaves the life that he holds dear. Isnt that sad ?

Score: 3
Advertisement