UK & World News

  • 10 May 2012, 0:17

Doctors Urged: Don't Use The Word 'Obese'

Doctors have been told not to use the word "obese" for fear of upsetting patients.

Instead they should encourage people to aim for a "healthier weight", according to new advice from an NHS watchdog.

Health campaigners have dismissed the approach as "absurd".

The National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (Nice) says in draft guidance that "obesity" can be used within the medical profession, but doctors and nurses should be cautious about using it in front of patients.

The document warns: "The term 'obesity' may be unhelpful - while some people like to 'hear it like it is', others may consider it derogatory."

It adds: "It might be better to refer to a 'healthier weight' rather than 'obesity' - and to talk more generally about health and wellbeing."

Ironically, the advice is contained in a document titled 'Obesity: Working with Local Communities'.

But Tam Fry of the National Obesity Forum told Sky News a medical consultation about a weight problem was a time for "plain talking".

"Nice is being too nice. They are not exhibiting the tough love they should be.

"'Obesity' is a medical description. There is a defined point at which being overweight becomes a serious medical issue.

"It you skirt around the bushes you confuse people over how serious it is," he said

A spokesperson for Nice said the guidance had been put out for consultation.

"It is an evolving document," she said.

what do you think?

first 20 comments

Julie Crumpton

3:18pm on 9/5/2012

Well what do you call it then.........weightily challenged?

Score: 12
1 reply

Windows Live User

3:29pm on 9/5/2012

Size of some of these people I would be wary calling them any names at all. We are all ever so perfect are we not? Cant wait for the responses more name calling of the first order undoubtedly

Score: 6

Juls Adams

3:21pm on 9/5/2012

sorry i have to say your blood to fat consistancy looks like lard and you have the profile of the michieln man and i suggust you dont go swimming has you might sink or remove all the water or just obese its easier

Score: 9
1 reply

Windows Live User

3:25pm on 9/5/2012

wouldnt like a smack around the ear for calling him names? Strange how we are oh so quick to have a dig at another person even when we dont know the circumstances

Score: 9

Jan N Andy Oakley-Hills

3:23pm on 9/5/2012

Just call them FAT and be done with it, time people faced up to the truth, stop namby pamby rubbish.

Score: 15
1 reply

Jim England

3:29pm on 9/5/2012

Well said.

Score: 7

Jim England

3:28pm on 9/5/2012

What a stupid Leftie idea. Let's tiptoe around them for fear of "offending" them. I'm offended that these self-pitying, lazy, greedy people are allowed gastric bands ect on the NHS, or worse still that a significant number of them exist on benefits. There's something so vulgar about our country these days, that people have become so hideously huge, so selfish, have no understanding of proper diet and no real work ethic. That people can reach such a disgusting size whilst the taxpayer pays for it. They have no dignity, humility or respect for anyone or anything, they do not appreciate the food they receive. They need to experience some true austerity. The hard truth is what they need. MOVE MORE. EAT LESS! Stop blaming everyone else for your bloated state and STOP whining and complaining becuase a doctor has told you what you NEED to be told!

Score: 16
3 replies

ffreem200

6:50pm on 9/5/2012

Ure statement is rather inaccurate

Score: 6

joelle cooke

7:01pm on 9/5/2012

well said

Score: 4

Chris Carr

8:25pm on 9/5/2012

I'm inclined to agree with some of your sentiments but not all fat people are on the dole or getting fat at taxpayers' expense. Some are doing it with their own money.

Score: 6

Richard Tobin

3:34pm on 9/5/2012

Just call me fat i can take it

Score: 10
2 replies

Joan Holmes

7:40pm on 9/5/2012

Very well said, Nobody ever left a concentration camp fat or even a bit plump !!!

Score: 3

Mat Eaton

10:42pm on 9/5/2012

You're fat!!! ;)

Score: 1

John Mechelen

3:37pm on 9/5/2012

Six months holiday,to Ethiopia should cure them.Plenty of sun,no tv work hard.

Score: 6
1 reply

Thomas Jenkinson

4:55pm on 9/5/2012

Be careful they might become food like a fat white cow (human) lol

Score: 6

Michael Jordan

3:57pm on 9/5/2012

Give the Doctors some credit they know just how to pass bad news on to their patients. A man walks into his clothes store with a note from his Doctor.

Score: 6

j.r.haynes

4:51pm on 9/5/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

Steve Marshall

5:06pm on 9/5/2012

I was quite pleased when the doc said i was obese, i thought i was morbidly obese.

Score: 13
1 reply

movvi

7:36pm on 9/5/2012

Ha ha ha!

Score: 3

David Wragg

5:59pm on 9/5/2012

No, I agree, don't beat about the bush. Use sympathetic medical terms like 'gross', 'fat' or 'bloated'.

Score: 5

Neil Foster

6:39pm on 9/5/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

ffreem200

6:47pm on 9/5/2012

I am classified as clinically obese and am not offended by it. I would just like to clear up tho that not all obese people are on the dole coating tax payers money and costing Nhs thousands as I am employed and doing something about my weight without the need of the NHS

Score: 10
2 replies

Joan Holmes

7:42pm on 9/5/2012

We all wish there were more like you then, and very best wishes, hope you reach your goal

Score: 5

ffreem200

7:49pm on 9/5/2012

Thanks for the supportive reply

Score: 4

Dawson Wilkins

7:13pm on 9/5/2012

Fat woman at the doctors because she's having health problems. The doctor says "Madam, your problems stem from your clinical obesity. Basically you're just too fat" "I object to that diagnosis" she says, "and I demand a second opinion, you rude man!" "Fair enough" says the doctor, "You're bloody ugly too!"

Score: 9

movvi

7:39pm on 9/5/2012

Yes - "Look, fatty, start using the stairs instead of the lift, or you'll have a heart attack, you bloater" would be far more sensitive...

Score: 6

Michael Hawkins

8:04pm on 9/5/2012

Next we will be reading doctors are not to tell families a relative is dying, they will be asked to use terms like dont bother to visit tommorow

Score: 6

Rhys Sage

8:06pm on 9/5/2012

Ah... Mr Jones... Everybody else but you is of normal or less weight. Isn't it time you went on an exercise programme to lose all that blubber?

Score: 3

Chris Carr

8:26pm on 9/5/2012

Surely the Nice people have more important things to worry about. Like the approving life prolonging drugs for the terminally ill? perhaps there is a clue in the title: they are just too NICE.

Score: 3

Bernadette Griffin

9:47pm on 9/5/2012

Oh dear political correctness gone crazy. Wasn't obese supposed to be used instead of fat - less upsetting?

Score: 5

June Oldham

9:57pm on 9/5/2012

the use of certain language by what is meant to be a caring profession is actually inflammatory to the patient as well as many observers. you can see a direct link between these inflammatory "legal" expressions and current attitudes. seems to be breeding an ignorant attitude in the masses - mostly the younger age groups - as we can clearly see in many of the statements made here. money's on under 30s. i could go on. the labour government! a spade is a spade rubbish. heedbangers, with much love to see the back of them.

Score: 2

Mike Drouin

7:36am on 10/5/2012

WHY ? is it because the truth sometimes hurts well tuff!!!!!!!!!

Score: 5
Advertisement