UK & World News

  • 3 October 2012, 2:59

Ed Miliband: I Want To Create One Nation

Ed Miliband has delivered a highly-personal speech in which he insisted Labour is now the "One Nation" party.

The Labour leader borrowed the One Nation slogan first used by Tory prime minister Benjamin Disraeli in the 19th century and long linked to the political centre-right.

He insisted David Cameron had lost his right to call himself a One Nation Prime Minister by cutting the top rate of tax and slashing services and benefits for the poor.

Britain can overcome the current challenges by coming together as it had in the past, he said, adding: "One nation: a country where everyone has a stake. One nation: a country where prosperity is fairly shared.

"One nation where we have a shared destiny, a sense of shared endeavour and a common life that we lead together. That is my vision of one nation, that is my vision of Britain, that is the Britain we must become."

The keynote address to the party conference in Manchester was deliberately very personal as Mr Miliband sought to recast himself as a man of the people.

It followed a new ComRes poll for the Independent which showed that just 22% of people believe he has what it takes to be a good Prime Minister.

Lasting more than an hour, it was delivered from memory with no notes at all in a move that will inevitably spark comparisons to key speeches made by Mr Cameron in 2005 and 2007.

Aides said Mr Miliband had written the speech himself in the past few weeks and decided to deliver it off the cuff in a bid to connect more with the audience.

It was light on policy announcements apart from widely trailed education reforms and was immediately criticised for only briefly mentioning the economy.

Mr Miliband did vow to split up the banks, repeal the controversial NHS reform Bill and establish an alternative to the A-level for the "forgotten 50%" who do not go to university.

But the focus was on his own philosophy, which he explained had been forged through his experiences as the child of Jewish refugees from Nazism and days at a London comprehensive school.

Mr Miliband said his political views were moulded after family friend Ruth First, a campaigner against apartheid in South Africa, was killed in a letter bomb attack.

He spoke of how his Jewish mother was rescued during the war by nuns and his father joined the Royal Navy after fleeing the Nazis.

"It is this upbringing who has made me a part of who I am - a person of faith, not of religious faith but a faith nonetheless. A faith I believe many people will recognise," he said.

"Here is my faith. I believe we have a duty to leave the world a better place than we found it. I believe we cannot shrug our shoulders at injustice and just say that is the way the world is, and I believe we can overcome any odds if we come together as people."

Attempting to contrast his life with the Home Counties upbringing of the Prime Minister, he says: "My conviction is rooted in my family's story, a story that starts 1,000 miles from here, because the Milibands haven't sat under the same oak tree for the last 500 years.

"My parents came to Britain as immigrants, Jewish refugees from the Nazis. I would not be standing here today without the compassion and tolerance of our great country, Great Britain, a country that my parents saw rebuilt after the Second World War."

Of his schooling at Haverstock School in North London, he adds: "I went to my local school with people from all backgrounds.

"My school taught us a lot more than just how to pass exams: it taught people how to get on with each other, whoever they are and wherever they were from."

There were only glancing references to internal party critics and the Liberal Democrats, with his fire mainly focused on the Tories and their record in office.

He argued that nothing had changed since 2010 and that the economy is now getting worse rather than better.

His accusation that the Tories had shown themselves to be "incompetent" despite believing "they were born to rule" brought the audience to its feet.

"Have you ever seen a more incompetent, hopeless, out-of-touch, U-turning, pledge-breaking, make-it-up-as-you-go-along, back-of-the-envelope, miserable shower than this Prime Minister and this Government?" he asked.

Attacking the move to slash the top rate of tax, he vowed that his government would govern for the public and private sectors, for the squeezed middle and for the poor.

And he sought to draw a distinction with past Labour leaders by insisting it would not be silent about irresponsibility at the top and would hold the most powerful in society to account.

Mr Miliband warned of further austerity to come as he insisted the country had to learn to live within its means, but he stressed that those with the "broadest shoulders" should suffer most.

He said: "Every time Britain has faced its gravest challenge we have only come through the storm because we were one nation."

Immediately after the address, general secretary of Unite Len McCluskey said it was a "tour de force" that showed the Labour leader is a prime minister in waiting.

Former labour leader Lord Kinnock added: "It was brilliant in all respects."

what do you think?

first 20 comments

Bazil Brush

6:33am on 2/10/2012

why havent i heard anything yet about our immigration problem and what they are going to do about the border control and millions who should not be here etc

Score: 27
13 replies

Paul Grice

8:17am on 2/10/2012

Brazil brush I don't know how you managed to get your comment posted Your not allowed to swear on here using words like immigration

Score: 21

Mick Salt

8:35am on 2/10/2012

Can I just ask you 2 questions, Bazil: 1) What immigration problem? Proportionately, we take fewer legal immigrants than the majority of developed countries. 2) Where do you get your figures from for illegals? I know that statistics on illegal immigrants are always going to be a bit inaccurate, but most estimates say 600,000 not millions (viz 1% of the population). To put it in to perspective again, the figure in Germany is 2% and in the USA 3% etc. So, in short, we don't have an immigrant problem, we have an illegal immigrant problem. We have to make a clear distinction. All governments in other developed countries recognise that legal immigration is a good thing. They don't see it as a problem, nor should it be for us.

Score: 25

gengisken1227

8:38am on 2/10/2012

Shhh Baz, don't ask difficult questions like immigration - British society hasn't yet been completely subverted.

Score: 17

gengisken1227

8:45am on 2/10/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 20

gengisken1227

8:47am on 2/10/2012

scarred for life

Score: 13

Mick Salt

9:22am on 2/10/2012

There'll always be a criminal element amongst immigrants, just as there's a criminal element amongst people born in this country. Why do you expect them to be different? The Spanish, French etc will probably tell you that there's a criminal element amongst British immigrants in their countries. My point is based on the fact that, in decades to come, all western developed countries will need a larger workforce to support an ageing population. Research done throughout Europe has indicated this need and that is why all European governments have allowed so many immigrants in - to prepare for the coming crisis.

Score: 17

Name witheld

10:41am on 2/10/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

Dave Harrison

10:49am on 2/10/2012

Mick. East european criminal gangs were allowed to come to the UK unhindered by the govts failure to impose any restrictions whatsoever when the EU was expanded to include Romania, Bulgaria etc

Score: 18

Mick Salt

11:24am on 2/10/2012

...and, Dave, many top British criminals were allowed to settle in Spain. If people break the law in Britain or Spain, then they are pursued by the law. The vast majority of immigrants to this country are law-abiding and hard working. According to the Institute of Fiscal Studies, they contribute £3 billion more in tax and NI than they consume in any forms of benefit. The popular view (incredibly) is that they sponge off benefits.

Score: 11

Scott Cooper

2:49pm on 2/10/2012

No good trying to reason with these people nick salt, I tried on several occasions they'd mostly extremists/racists that have no clue about the real world normal people like us live in.. In the end just agree bit add that every country should have the same policy so getting rid of a couple million immigrants and their families and in return get back 30 million from nz and oz alone (how many people in Canada are there another 100 million?)

Score: 9

jeni sperber

3:13pm on 2/10/2012

Mick don't waste your time. Thease people don't understand reality.

Score: 9

Mick Salt

3:57pm on 2/10/2012

I can, though, Scott & Jeni, understand why people hold such incredibly negative opinions of immigrants. For example, a couple of years ago over a 12 month period, the Daily Mail printed 9 stories of immigrants milking the system (living in 4 star hotels, being given 5 bedroom mansions etc). When these reports were investigated by a well known TV investigative program, they were all found to be total fabrications. Many of Ed Milliband's fellow Jews were victims of similar propaganda. We don't want anything like that to happen again, so better to speak out even if it makes us unpopular.

Score: 10

gengisken1227

4:07pm on 2/10/2012

Complete rubbish Mick Salt, there is no need to import additional people into this country to deal with age demographics when there are untrained and unskilled young native Britons available, wasting their lives in unemployment on benefits. PC driven education has completely failed to provide technical training which was not the case in the past. The socialist utopia of everyone being equal education, has led to children wasting 11 years of their formative years being unable almost illiterate and only partially numerate that when BAE sought trainee engineers, they were forced to search overseas.

Score: 11

blue side

7:24am on 2/10/2012

So he plans to make all the kids of equal academic standards so does that mean they will all be geniuses or all illiterate? He omits to say also from his comprehensive came Boris Johnson and alike. He omits to say he came from a wealthy part of North London but plays the poor Jewish refugees and the N a z i playing card. Sorry Ed you are a hypocrite. I know guys who came from real poverty one of whom is a doctor and the other a multi millionaire: those with the ability and drive can achieve but your plan will create a nation of free riders and false hopes.

Score: 27
1 reply

Michael Dynes

11:53am on 2/10/2012

Oh Blue side, that was wonderfully put. Your first question was excellent. I agree with you wholeheartedly. Milliband did not go to some back street comp and had to rough it with the "real" underclass. Mark Twain had it when he said how funny it was, that the harder he worked the more luckier he became.

Score: 8

Paul Grice

7:43am on 2/10/2012

never had problems like this forty years ago I left school without taking my GCSEs to start an apprenticeship. Did night school and day release . Rubbed shoulders with university educated people and to be honest they actually know less than the ones who like myself were comprehensive educated. Today the problem we have schools don't educate they teach, SchoolsTeach how to pass an exam not educate you in the subject . University educate if the student wants to be educated now the costs of going to uni are high the free loaders going to uni instead of work can't do it now they have to get a job or go on benefits . Education only works if you wish yo be educated and to just add another worthless peace of paper is a wast of time and money but it might make the jobless figures look better .

Score: 22
5 replies

Steve Barker

8:36am on 2/10/2012

Obviously you didn't study English at night school.

Score: 9

Windows Live User

9:45am on 2/10/2012

Many years ago I worked overseas for an engineering company that chose to employ a British Works Engineer, Uni educated with degrees. He turned out to be the most embarrassing Brit I had come across. He came out with the most ludicrous engineering ideas and proposals. None of which were achievable within the company. It was months later (long after he was fired as one would expect) before others in the company stopped referring to him and glancing in my direction (fellow Brit). Me? I had a tech college / apprenticeship background which more than held it's own against their home grown people

Score: 9

Name witheld

9:54am on 2/10/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

Andrea Hill

10:09am on 2/10/2012

paul is right though.

Score: 5

Andrea Hill

10:33am on 2/10/2012

i know window life user, some dont have an ounce.of common sense.

Score: 12

john

8:15am on 2/10/2012

Just follow the example of the elite, Ed, small class numbers, it seems to work for Eton and Rugby etc.

Score: 14

Name witheld

8:17am on 2/10/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 15

Mick Daniel

8:19am on 2/10/2012

Not only is he an ignorant fool he is also a hypocrit. Class warriers make me sick, they have the inability to judge people as people, irrelevnt of their background

Score: 21

Neil C

8:41am on 2/10/2012

Division, nice one you idiot. If your from a different background so what!! You are what you are, you can't have a go at people because the parents worked and did well and then passed this on to the children. Get up and get out and graft in life, this idiot can't relate either to people so what's the change. He's gonna play the race card today, "I came from a humble back ground look at me blah blah blah!!!"

Score: 14
1 reply

Name witheld

2:20pm on 2/10/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

Edgar Beckett

9:17am on 2/10/2012

" a country that my parents saw rebuilt after the Second World War " ! and now it needs to be rebuilt again ? Lucky thing that we have a few green fields left to build it on.

Score: 15
2 replies

Name witheld

2:19pm on 2/10/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

Robert Hare

3:06pm on 2/10/2012

One day Edgar there will be an Almighty rumbling under your feet,there will be so many people living on this island that it will be an earthquake and UK will break up and crumble into the sea disappearing off the map

Score: 11

Howard Kingsbury

10:51am on 2/10/2012

Here we go again! Dear Old Labour trying to capitalise on the envy of the proletariat. If only the electorate at large could see this poison for what it is, the UK might lift its head again.

Score: 19

Phil A

11:08am on 2/10/2012

If we had practised elitism we wouldn't have these half wits in charge of the country. The whole point of the degree was to show that you were in the top 5%. Today it means you are in the tp 50% and if the Governent has its way it will mean you are in the top 95%.

Score: 14
1 reply

Andrea Hill

4:29pm on 2/10/2012

too many going to uni getn mediocre degrees. we need change

Score: 6

Peter Edwardson

11:53am on 2/10/2012

Restricting the children that want to succeed and have the means to do so will not improve the standards for the rest. If you have the intelligence to succeed and you are prepared to work for it you will, no mater what school or background you come from. It has been proved many times over that government intervention with socialist ideas does not work. It does not raise the standards but reduces them to the lowest level. For those of a mathematical back ground this is known as the lowest common denominator theory.

Score: 13
3 replies

MichaelStinton

12:41pm on 2/10/2012

What rubbish Peter! What proof? Elitism helps the elite most. I agree the exceptional will break through in any system but the exceptional are the few, surely we must put more effort into the many!

Score: 9

Mike Drouin

4:07pm on 2/10/2012

it just makes goverment personal feel better .

Score: 3

Andrea Hill

4:31pm on 2/10/2012

you are right peter.

Score: 6

Michael Dynes

12:07pm on 2/10/2012

In Germany engineers have the same esteem as a doctor, but not over here. I am in awe of engineers. I can transfer a picture on my desk onto my computer screen with the press of a button, an engineer was behind that. I have worked with academics and I have this theory that the higher up the academic tree you climb, the thicker you become. I can say this because I have been clinically defined as a genius. The academic route is not the cleverest. If you want the evidence, look at the idiots (all parties) running the country.

Score: 11
2 replies

Name witheld

1:14pm on 2/10/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

Mike Drouin

4:05pm on 2/10/2012

totaly correct

Score: 4

Michael Dynes

12:09pm on 2/10/2012

I think Blue side belowl makes a cracking point. We do not have parity of esteem between technical courses and academic courses. This comes from an historic ignorance in this country about what education is. I remember a school teacher who took her charges to a chemical engineering plant. As the kids were getting on the bus, she told them that they had better work hard at school or they would end up like them, pointing to Chemical Engineers. Those engineers had a much better degree than hers, had to work for them a darn sight harder and were on probs three times more salary than her.

Score: 11
1 reply

Mike Drouin

4:04pm on 2/10/2012

the old and very true fact . those that can do those that cant teach ( generally very poorly )

Score: 6

Neil C

2:20pm on 2/10/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Jan N Andy Oakley-Hills

3:29pm on 2/10/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

shirley sutton

3:30pm on 2/10/2012

One nation how we going to have that when we can't get rid of unwanted people who should be extradited cos they keep appealing - get rid of all the foreign scrounges if you've got the guts to do it

Score: 17
1 reply

Mike Drouin

4:01pm on 2/10/2012

certainly the milliband idiot is never going to achieve anything .

Score: 6

Jan N Andy Oakley-Hills

3:43pm on 2/10/2012

WHAT WE NEED IS A PARTY FOR THE PEOPLE,WITH PRIORITY 1 TO GET US OUT OF EUROPE FAST 2 TO STOP IMMIGRATION AND RETURN ALL ILLEGALS WITH NO POWER OF APPEAL 3 STOP BUILDING ON FOOD PRODUCING LAND BEFORE WE ARE STARVED INTO SUBMISSION 4 RESTRICT FAMILY CREDIT TO 2 CHILDREN AND ONLY IF MARRIED 5 NO FAMILY CREDIT/BENEFITS FOR ANY IMMIGRANTS UNTIL THEY HAVE LIVED AND WORKED IN THE UK FOR 5 YRS MIN. 6 REDUCE THE NO OF MPS BY HALF, RECRUIT ONLY PEOPLE WITH PROPER BUSINESS EXPERIENCE, MAKE THEM GIVE UP ALL OTHER DIRECTORSHIPS, AND CLOCK IN TO DO A FULL WEEK'S WORK IN GOVERNMENT, REDUCE THEIR EXPENSES AND RESTRICT THEIR SALARY, AND THEN YOU MIGHT GET SOME BRIGHT, INTELLIGENT, PEOPLE WITH INTEGRITY AND GENUINE CONCERN TO GET THIS COUNTRY ON ITS FEET AGAIN.

Score: 24
2 replies

Mike Drouin

3:59pm on 2/10/2012

i like it jan everything i believe in but if only it were to happen what a joyous country this would be .

Score: 12

happymike CHESTER

4:04pm on 2/10/2012

The Germans did that in the 30`s and 40`s ended up with a loss of 55.million people dead. Business people do not make good rulers only a cross section of society from All walks of life.

Score: 8

happymike CHESTER

3:56pm on 2/10/2012

David Camoron will repeat the same speech next week all rhetoric with no meaning and no true believes . Just politics of self interest. The Anarchists seem a better alternative.

Score: 17

Windows Live User

4:02pm on 2/10/2012

What is Mr Miliband's stance on the ever-increasing giving of money to overseas. To peoples that don't like us, in an attempt to become friends. Meanwhile Britain's pensioners struggle hard to make ends meet with ever increasing food bills. Rocketing heating and lighting bills. Granny tax. The closing of services. Now a tax for an empty room for council house occupants.( If they want me to move into a single room bungalow then I would go, funny thing is they don't have them!! so instead I will be taxed or be dam.ned). Responsible pensioners who are consistently marginalised, exploited, excluded, and ignored by UK Government.

Score: 12

Jonathan Goodwin-Self

4:32pm on 2/10/2012

If you make any comment then orange is as bad as Cameron. They ignore the entire country

Score: 6
Advertisement