UK & World News
Footballer Jailed After Raping Teen In Hotel
Sheffield United and Wales striker Ched Evans has been found guilty of raping a woman who was "too drunk to consent" to sex - and jailed for five years.
His co-accused, Port Vale defender Clayton McDonald, was found not guilty of the same charge.
In sentencing at Caernarfon Crown Court, Judge Merfyn Hughes QC told Evans: "You have thrown away the successful career in which you were involved.
"As the jury have found, she was in no condition to have sexual intercourse. When you arrived at the hotel, you must have realised that."
Evans' legal team issued a statement immediately after the verdict repeating his claim of innocence and hinting at an appeal, while Sheffield United said it would respond to the sentence only after it had "taken sufficient time to consider the matter fully".
Mr McDonald had hugged a sobbing Evans after receiving his not guilty verdict, which saw court proceedings briefly adjourned due to Mr McDonald's supporters cheering in the public gallery.
But when the judge returned to court and the guilty verdict was returned for Evans, the footballer looked shocked and threw the headphones he was using to follow the trial on the floor.
The two footballers, who are both 23 and first met when they were both at the Manchester City youth academy, were accused of raping a 19-year-old woman in a hotel room last year.
Evans, originally from St Asaph, Denbighshire, and now of Penistone, South Yorkshire, and Mr McDonald of Crewe, Cheshire, admitted having sex with the woman on May 30, 2011, but said it was consensual.
The jury had been told that after seeing the "dangerously intoxicated" woman fall over in kebab shop in Rhyl, Mr McDonald got into a taxi with her to a Premier Inn hotel.
He then sent a text to Evans stating he had "got a bird", the court heard.
During Evans' evidence, he told the jury he had gone to the hotel room, let himself into Mr McDonald's room and watched his friend have sex with the woman.
He said Mr McDonald asked if his friend could join in, to which the woman said yes. Mr McDonald later left the room.
But the woman, who cannot be named, said she had no memory of travelling to the Premier Inn and feared her drink had been spiked.
She claimed she could not remember the events that followed but recollected waking up naked, alone and confused some hours later.
But defending Mr McDonald, Lloyd Morgan said the woman had approached him and was "capable of making decisions".
Evans, who signed in a deal worth around £3m in 2009, has scored 34 goals for Sheffield United this season and was the club's player of the month for March. He has 13 caps and two goals for Wales.
what do you think?

Brian Mckeown
here we go again footballers are a magnet for women

Tim Hubble
5 years for rape is a joke. The woman suffers a life sentence every day

Lorna Jenkins
Sentencing for rape has always been a joke in my view,judges do not seem to have any idea of the devastating effects it can have,however although I am not blaming her I do think young women should think before going out drinking the way they do now and not go off with someone they don't know whether he is a famous footballer or not.

Malcolm Gylee
Being young and rich does not mean that they are above the law - if he did it, he must accept the consequences of his actions!

Pete Maidment
about time ,,,a footballer that isnt above the law,,,and i agree with tim,,,only five years,,its a joke

Richard D
Let's be frank; neither footballers nor any other well financed or "celebrity" persons are above the law. But their money does enable them to get the best of lawyers and then in court it becomes the survival of the cleverest...

Pete Maidment
reading your reply,,basically its survival of the richest rather than the cleverst then

Tim Hubble
What's all this nonsense about if he did it? He has been convicted in a court of law in UK. Are we doubting the conviction because he is a footballer? Oh sorry they are above the law I forgot. .

Jamie Smith
How can one be guilty and the other not if the woman was in no fit state to consent to sex when both of the men had sex with her?

TheKarmacanic
I have to agree Jamie. It does seem odd that they weren't both found guilty! But I guess the fact that she specifically went back to the hotel with one of the footballer's has clouded the issue. I think he was lucky to get off!

Richard D
I think Paul Hayes is very close to the truth. The point is, without hearing the evidence in its entirety, we cannot be sure of how the evidence led to the actions of each man being differentiated.

Nicola Anderson
@ Ian Harris Why can't men go 5 minuets without raping everything in sight? It's like your animals ad not people with no sentient self control. Someone very dear to me lost her virginity to a date-rape like this because her sisters ad a reputation and I feel sick to think that there are people out there who would think she deservedit. I've seen plently of drunk men in my time and have never raped a single one. It's not difficult people.

TheKarmacanic
Well said Nicola. I think Ian Harris is being deliberately provocative, so I'd best ignore him! Please don't lump all us men together, as were not all bad. But I know what you mean about some men. There are a large proportion of Neanderthal men that make me feel ashamed to male at times!

joelle cooke
most man are animals,reptile,always on the look out,they are hunters,they want sex,and they don`t want to ask,they just drug women,goes quicker,you are lucky,make sure it stays like this.

Chris Everson
Totally agree with Joelle about SOME men. You can't lump all men in the same bracket as those sc*mbags. It's like me branding all young women as alcopop gorging slags isn't it? It's just not true. I'd also add to joelle that her rant is just paranoid idiocy that hinders rather than helps anything. And being petty... most men know punctuation. Let's not turn this into a rant against men in general. I've never considered rape, and the idea appals me. As it does most men.

Richard D
Generalizations help nobody ,but I also fully understand that stories such as this makes many people's blood boil and that leads to extreme emotion and extreme comments. I think when anybody gets so legless they don't even know what they are doing or what time of day it is, regardless of gender, they reap what they sow. Having said that, anybody who takes advantage of such idiots are beneath contempt and when it involes a crime there can be no excuse. Even if a person says "Yes" while out of it, any right minded person should not take the "yes" as true consent while intoxication lasts. Sadly, not everybody is right minded and horniness is not an excuse.

Paul Hayes
I don't understand this one. How can one of them be charged with rape, and the other one walk away with a not-guilty verdict?! Surely they're either both guilty or both not guilty as the sex took place simultaneously?

TheKarmacanic
If you read the article Paul, it says that McDonald left the room. Which implies Evans also had sex separately.

Nic Smith
I agree with TheKarmacanic, if he did this then he deserves to be punished. In respect of the other comment that stated why are we questioning whether he did or didnt do this when he has been found guilty in a court of law, there are such things as miscarriages of justice. In respect of another comment that states that at last a footballer has been brought to task and isn't above the law, I just hope this guy has not been used as some scape goat to prove this point. Although I obviously do not agree with a man taking advantage of a woman when she is clearly under the influence, surely women have a duty to protect themselves by not getting absolutely legless to the point they do not know what they are doing? Regret for ones actions and guilt is a powerful emotion but taking responsibility for your own behaviour is called being an adult.

Julie Crumpton
I so agree!

Alan Pollard
lads go out on a Saturday night to get drunk and pull - so do girls. However, when a girl is drunk, then sex becomes rape. I think the man has been punished so heavilly because of his status as a public figure, but it does make a statement to all lads wanting a good time. I do think that from what had been said in court, the girl may have given confusing signals, but if she was too drunk to say no, then the right decision was reached.

George Clement
Why only one found guilty? There's something drastically wrong here. The one who takes the legless girl in the taxi to the hotel then texts his mate to come and join him gets off????????????

Julie Crumpton
I fully agree with verdict, HOWEVER! For girls to get so drunk, they dont know what the hell they are doing, is, as proven, bloody dangerous! If this girl was on her own, how come? Where were friends? There is never an excuse for rape, EVER! But, im sorry, this girl did not help herself, lessons to be learned!

denis parsons
He could've said no,but he didn't,instead, the DEVIL was in him that night and as the woman was drunk he thought she would not remember the incident.She said she didn't remember the incident,but seemed to remember who did it.That's a bit weird.








TheKarmacanic
4:01pm on 20/4/2012
If Evan's is indeed guilty, this is a well deserved and just punishment! He will have the next few years to reflect on his disgusting crime and mourn the loss of a promising career.