UK & World News

  • 16 October 2012, 11:07

House Fire: Motive Sought Over Family Deaths

Police say a doctor who lost his wife and four children in a suspected arson attack on their home in Essex "fought hard" to save them.

Four of the victims - Sabah Usmani, who was also a doctor, and her sons Sohaib, 13, and Rayyan, six, and 11-year-old daughter Hira - died in the blaze in Barn Mead, Harlow, in the early hours of Monday.

A third son, nine-year-old Muneeb, was rescued with his three-year-old sister Maheen. Both were taken to the town's Princess Alexandra Hospital in a critical condition, but Muneeb died later.

Maheen remains critical and has been transferred to a specialist burns unit at the Broomfield hospital in Chelmsford.

The children's father, Dr Abdul Shakoor, works at the Princess Alexandra Hospital where he is being treated for minor burns and smoke inhalation. His condition is described as stable.

Dr Shakoor apparently escaped the fire by jumping from a first-floor window and is said by police to have "fought hard to save his family in appalling conditions". He is not being treated as a suspect.

Police are working to establish a possible motive for the attack. There had been no previous problems with racism in the area, although there have been other arson attacks on cars nearby, officers said.

One possible line of enquiry is that the family were not the intended target of the attackers.

Witness reports suggest between one and four people were in the area at the time. Such sightings will form a key part of the investigation, police said.

Assistant Chief Constable Gary Beautridge said: "In the history of Essex Police, seldom has there been an incident of this gravity, in which five people, four of them children, have lost their lives.

"I would like to stress that the father of these children was in the property at the time and fought hard to save his family in appalling conditions."

Mr Beautridge said Dr Shakoor was "in severe shock". He added: "Our work with (him) to establish some of the facts of this case will, inevitably, take time because of the emotional trauma he has suffered."

One neighbour told Sky News the doctor was in his dressing gown, screaming "get my family out" and had to be physically restrained from going inside the house.

Emergency services were called to Barn Mead at 1.48am. They found a burning car and an end-of-terrace house "engulfed" with flames coming out of the front and back doors.

Firefighters wearing breathing equipment battled "punishing" conditions inside before pulling out six people, Chief Fire Officer David Johnson, from Essex Fire and Rescue, told Sky News.

It is believed the fire started downstairs.

Mr Johnson said: "The first crews that arrived were actually confronted initially by a car that was alight so thought they were dealing with a car fire, but almost immediately became aware that there was a very developed house fire almost adjacent to where the car fire was.

"It was a very, very, hot, intense fire."

Because of its ferocity detectives are investigating whether it was started with some kind of fuel. The house has been sealed off for forensic examination.

Although the blazing Ford car found nearby was not connected with the family, it is also being treated as arson. Mr Johnson said it was highly likely the two fires were related.

Originally from Karachi, Pakistan, Dr Shakoor and his wife lived in Saudi Arabia, where their children were born, before moving to Manchester and then Harlow.

Mrs Usmani was also a doctor, although she stayed at home and cared for the children.

Parvez Hamid, 43, and Safia Anwar, 38, have known the couple since they moved to Harlow in 2011.

Their children attended the nearby Abbotsweld Primary School with some of the Shakoor children.

Mrs Anwar said: "They were a wonderful family. The children were best friends with our own.

"We would see them at (the) mosque and at the school gates. They were just such a lovely family.

"I last saw Sabah on Friday. She seemed normal with no worries at all.

"I heard what happened from a friend who lived nearby. It has come as such a shock to us all and it is still sinking in. We are absolutely devastated."

Mr Hamid said: "Their children were so well behaved and I was always envious that mine weren't the same.

"They were hardworking parents who will be missed. The Asian community is very tight-knit in this area and we are all in shock."

Workers at the Princess Alexandra Hospital have told Sky News Dr Shakoor was a highly respected member of staff.

Chief Executive Melanie Walker said: "The hospital is deeply saddened by the tragic circumstances which have occurred."

Detective Superintendent Rob Vinson, who is leading the inquiry, said it was likely the fire was started deliberately and asked anyone with information to contact police.

He said the local community and Islamic groups could hold the answer, adding: "I fully appreciate the community will be devastated. Nobody expects such a catastrophic incident in their own neighbourhood."

Update:

Hello, regular commenting on Orange News and Sport pages closes on Thursday 30 May 2013. We will continue to provide a commenting facility on major news and sport events on orangeworld.co.uk. Contact us via http://oran.ge/OWfeedback if you have any further questions. Thanks.

what do you think?

first 20 comments

shaun spencer

7:19am on 15/10/2012

Terribly sad.rip little ones.rip mum.hope your together somewhere.

Score: 21

Kerry Dodd Kandola

8:03am on 15/10/2012

Oh my god. How awful. Rip. X

Score: 12

mark townend

8:33am on 15/10/2012

Awww no..r.i.p liitle ones and mum. My thoughts are with you x

Score: 11

andy johnson

8:47am on 15/10/2012

seems to be a lot of fires recently rip

Score: 9

ali baba

1:57pm on 15/10/2012

how sad RIP

Score: 7

shaun spencer

2:14pm on 15/10/2012

Whoever puts the thumbs down to these comments needs help.you need to see a pschiatrist.

Score: 19
7 replies

Gillian Silcox

2:26pm on 15/10/2012

I agree with you Shaun, they must be a very sad individual.

Score: 14

shaun spencer

3:34pm on 15/10/2012

Normally i dont take much notice of the thumbs up or down,but on a post like this i found it very irritating,uppsetting and annoying.

Score: 14

Jasmin Louise

5:03pm on 15/10/2012

Shaun, they're numpties. Some sick individuals out there eh?

Score: 8

movvi

5:39pm on 15/10/2012

Nothing else to do, obviously! x

Score: 9

ffreem200

6:04pm on 15/10/2012

Exactly Shaun. Some people just do it for confrontation regardless of the story. There is 5 people died n someone has still decided to mark them down. Get a life who ever has done this rip n hope ure all together.

Score: 7

Kerry Dodd Kandola

6:11pm on 15/10/2012

I was just thinking the same...

Score: 4

Lorgar Aurelian

7:28pm on 15/10/2012

Nothing but trolls and best ignored.

Score: 9

rfbevan

2:29pm on 15/10/2012

If this, what it looks like it is, a racist attack, it is appalling and somebody needs to pay the utlimate penalty

Score: 21
3 replies

ali baba

2:36pm on 15/10/2012

disturbing if it is a racist attack.

Score: 8

Adj Jackson

3:44pm on 15/10/2012

Could be another of those cowardly honour killings nobody knows the true facts yet!!!! Very very sad however

Score: 13

Princess Angelique

10:28pm on 15/10/2012

Why is it appalling if it was a racist attack? It's appalling no matter what the motivation!!

Score: 4

Brian E Gorton

3:32pm on 15/10/2012

What is this country coming to. Racist or not this is shocking,how can someone do this.We have some very evil creatures with us!! We the people of Britain must put a stop to this kind of atrocity.Your God be with you Mother and Children RIP.I am so sad for the family.

Score: 11

Brian E Gorton

3:41pm on 15/10/2012

Look at the picture of the children.How could someone do this.I can't believe this!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Score: 11

Tricky One

3:44pm on 15/10/2012

horiffic

Score: 9

Jasmin Louise

5:28pm on 15/10/2012

I just hope those that vote peoples condolence messages down! Never have to go through a terrible tragedy like this. Especially when young children are involved! Normal human reaction is to feel sympathy....nuff said!!!

Score: 14

movvi

5:54pm on 15/10/2012

Horrendous. Poor things.

Score: 8

Bernadette Griffin

5:57pm on 15/10/2012

If it is a deliberate act it's despicable that poor man.

Score: 9

andy may

7:53pm on 15/10/2012

poor poor family. lets hope the father and remaining daughter can recover from this and lead some kind of a life.

Score: 7

Sharon Ridgeway Ahmadi

9:47pm on 15/10/2012

So sad.. R.I.P little Angels... :-( much love xxxxxxx

Score: 7
1 reply

David Roberts

7:09am on 16/10/2012

why the minus score by some?

Score: 2

Danny Cooper

11:17pm on 15/10/2012

as sad as this is, i cant help but ask why the race card has been pulled out. if it was a white family with asians living by it would of just been a terrible accident and nothing more... i am in no way racist but wonder why, as soon as an incident happens. involving non-whites, there is the huge question of wether its race related

Score: 7
2 replies

David Roberts

8:10am on 16/10/2012

That is often driven by the media. This case may have been religion-fuelled as are a lot of crimes.

Score: 5

Danny Cooper

8:45am on 16/10/2012

possibly, but as there have been other cases of arson in the area, unless they were all aimed at ethnic or religious minorities id say its not racially motivated.

Score: 3

Kimberley Lamb

5:33am on 16/10/2012

So sad . Terrible that someone thinks they have the right to kill a mother and her children . Disgusting !!! I hope they find them soon . Rest in peace . Xxx

Score: 7

David Roberts

7:07am on 16/10/2012

Now then now then now then draft in the officers involved with the Savile matter - they probably need a break from their ordeal. Better still wait for Milliband to hold an independent inquiry and some resignations.

Score: 4

David Roberts

7:13am on 16/10/2012

Strange that with a report like this the monitor does not step in to remove the negative scoring and comments - why?

Score: 4

Louise Smith

10:10am on 16/10/2012

It really is a dreadful case......I hope the persons responsible for this crime are soon caught and dealt with. This is truly dispicable.... My thoughts are with the Dr. and his remaining family. God bless.

Score: 1
Advertisement