UK & World News

  • 16 September 2012, 22:57

Slurry Tank Tragedy: Rugby Star Among Dead

Ulster Rugby player Nevin Spence has died alongside his father and brother after an accident at a slurry tank on the family's farm in County Down, Northern Ireland.

Sky News Ireland Correspondent David Blevins said the tragedy began when the 22-year-old rugby star's father Noel fell into the tank as he tried to rescue the family dog.

Nevin's brother Graham went to the aid of his father, but was overcome by fumes. Nevin and his sister Emma then tried to save both their father and brother.

All three men lost their lives. Two died at the scene, the third was pronounced dead on arrival at a nearby hospital.

Emma Spence, an artist well known for her paintings of Ulster rugby players, is being treated for fume inhalation.

Nevin Spence was a member of the Ulster Rugby squad that reached the European Heineken Cup final last season, and he was predicted to have a successful international career ahead of him.

He had made an impressive 43 appearances for Ulster. He had also played for Ireland's Under 20s and received a call up for last year's six nations.

Ulster Rugby chief executive Shane Logan, and director of rugby David Humphreys, paid tribute to the young star at a news conference in Belfast.

Mr Logan said Nevin died with an "immense future in front of him".

"In his 22 years he was a model individual and a model professional," Mr Logan said.

"He was a man of absolute integrity, complete determination, great humility, a fine team player and an all-round exceptional individual."

Mr Humphreys described Nevin as "a dream player to work with".

"He was one of those players you sat down to talk about what his future held, (and) where he saw his future going. He had a very simple answer," Mr Humphreys said.

"He was born in Ulster, he came through school in Ulster, he played rugby for Ulster, and all he wanted to do for the remainder of his career was stay here, win trophies and be successful with Ulster."

Off the pitch, Nevin spoke publicly of his deep Christian faith and regularly took part in church services.

The player's agent, Cornerflag Management, released a statement saying: "It was with great sadness and deep regret that we learned of the sudden and tragic passing of Nevin, his father Noel and brother Graham in an accident on their family farm on Saturday afternoon.

"Our thoughts and prayers are with the Spence family at this extremely sad time."

Northern Ireland First Minister Peter Robinson said on Twitter: "Deeply saddened to hear of the tragedy in Hillsborough this evening. My thoughts and prayers are with family at this time of devastation."

Emergency services were called to the scene in Drumlough Road in Hillsborough, at around 6:00pm.

They found all four members of the family in the tank.

On many farms, slurry - a combination of cow manure and water - is stored in a special tank until it is ready to be applied to the land as fertiliser for plants.

The Northern Ireland Fire and Rescue Service said: "Three people were unconscious and NIAS paramedics commenced resuscitation efforts immediately assisted by other ambulance personnel.

"One of the four showed initial signs of responding to the efforts of the crews and was transported immediately to the nearby Lagan Valley Hospital, where unfortunately he died a short time later.

"Despite the best efforts of all involved the other two men died at the scene.

"A female was treated at the scene and taken to the Royal Victoria Hospital where she is recovering from the effects of fume inhalation."

Blevins said: "The family are well known and well respected in their local community and in Northern Ireland as a whole."

He said it was not uncommon for farm workers to fall into a slurry tank, and sometimes two people have to be rescued when someone climbs in to help them.

But he said it was very unusual for four people to be pulled from a tank.

Tributes poured in from across the rugby world and beyond for the sportsman and his family.

Former Ireland and Munster hooker Jerry Flannery tweeted: "Terrible news on Nevin Spence, his Brother and their Dad. Offering up prayers for their family and friends, unbelievably sad."

Northern Ireland golfer Rory McIlroy also tweeted his condolences, saying: "Just heard the tragic news of Nevin Spence and his family. Makes you cherish every day you have on this Earth."

The Ulster Farmers' Union said the tragedy had shocked the entire farming community.

UFU president Harry Sinclair said: "On behalf of all our members, I would like to extend our deepest sympathies to the family involved.

"This news has shocked the farming community.  Our thoughts are with the family and friends of the three men who have so tragically lost their lives."

what do you think?

14 comments

gypsy56

8:22pm on 15/9/2012

I think this is more of a lead story than that of little princess katie showing her bits off in public, and it was on public display - there were others on the balcony other than her husband - are they not 'members of the public'!

Score: 19
8 replies

Kelly Lovatt

12:55am on 16/9/2012

So wots ur point? Pay respects to the deceased. If u want comment on p k do so on correct thread.

Score: 13

Kelly Lovatt

12:59am on 16/9/2012

If you are not paying respect to this but just voicing your opinion on Kate you on wrong page

Score: 12

Julie Crumpton

8:21am on 16/9/2012

Don't think gyp..sy meant any disrespect, I think I know the point she was trying to make....

Score: 12

Kelly Lovatt

9:20am on 16/9/2012

Know all

Score: 9

Julie Crumpton

3:20pm on 16/9/2012

Kelly, follow your own advice and show respect....don't try and start an arguement.....have you just joined....?

Score: 10

movvi

4:32pm on 16/9/2012

Yes, g*psy - it seems far more important! (Sorry - it seems that while Borringe will publish your name, it won't let the rest of us use it...)

Score: 5

Julie Crumpton

4:52pm on 16/9/2012

Wouldn't let me either, movvi, wonder why?

Score: 5

movvi

8:17pm on 16/9/2012

It would seem it's a derogatory term, though those featured on tv call themselves gyp*ies!

Score: 3

Kimberley Lamb

7:21am on 16/9/2012

Such a tragic loss of life . My heart is filled with such sad emotion for this family . May they all rest in peace x

Score: 4

Ian Bond

7:25am on 16/9/2012

Poor family, brave lad God bless

Score: 3

Julie Crumpton

7:59am on 16/9/2012

What a terrible tragedy....

Score: 3

Bernard Petrie

8:46am on 16/9/2012

Sad, prayers to all.

Score: 2

EQINOX187 .

9:15am on 16/9/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 9
4 replies

Mary Steel

9:46am on 16/9/2012

One fell in and the others in turn tried to rescue those who went in before them as I am sure anyone would to try and rescue their close family or even a stranger.

Score: 8

Vladtheinhaler .

9:47am on 16/9/2012

I bet all who read your comment can't believe how one dimensional your thinking is. How about this ; one man falls in the tank and shouts for help, another tries to help and is overcome and falls in, this repeats, and you have the end result. It happens in sea tragedies, as we have seen in the last year. One man attempts to rescue another, and both die. Stop trying to make a great mystery out of an all too common accident. Slurry tank deaths are not rare, this one just snowballed, but it's not a case for Sherlock Holmes. P.S. Orange, why does your silly bloody auto censor regard "f u m e s ", as an offensive word, when you have printed it in the passage . Getting worse by the minutes, why don't you overhaul the system. !!!!

Score: 10

movvi

4:08pm on 16/9/2012

The only oddity I find here is your response! The last three people could, for example, have planned to make a chain to the side of the tank - who knows? What I do know is that there are many multiple drownings, etc. due to the fact that most people try to attempt to save their loved ones in such situations.

Score: 8

Nicola Anderson

6:04pm on 16/9/2012

this has happened before in the states. someone tries to help and is overcome by gasses

Score: 2

Louise Smith

10:20am on 16/9/2012

Talented young man, very sad family now. God bless them. What a terrifying accident

Score: 5

Jack Martin

10:23am on 16/9/2012

What an awful way to die

Score: 3

Jasmin Louise

10:31am on 16/9/2012

Awful tragedy. Can users show some respect for those that want to leave condolences on this thread. Thank you. R.I.P

Score: 5

happymike CHESTER

3:24pm on 16/9/2012

Slurry tanks are dangerous places very slimy and slippery a tragic loss of life victim and brave rescuer`s ,all too common on farms. R.I.P.

Score: 4

shirley sutton

4:09pm on 16/9/2012

tragic, maybe they should put grills or barriers over them to stop this sort of accident occuring as its a common occurance on farms unfortunately this family they paid the ultimate price RIP

Score: 3

movvi

4:10pm on 16/9/2012

Nevin's poor mum has had a huge chunk of her family wiped out in one blow. A terrible story. What heroic kids, to try to save their dad and each other like this.

Score: 5
1 reply

Bernadette Griffin

5:22pm on 16/9/2012

It is indeed an awful tragedy.

Score: 3

Jim Ford

4:50pm on 16/9/2012

Terrible accident! I believe it's Hydrogen Sulphide gas that's the culprit. Hydrogen sulphide is the smell responsible for 'bad eggs'. The problem is that it quickly antitheses the sense of smell and kills in quite low concentrations. There was family on a cruise ship that was poisoned by hydrogen sulphide from a faulty sewage system, a few years back. ISTRC at least one person lost their life in that incident.

Score: 4
1 reply

Julie Crumpton

5:02pm on 16/9/2012

Really? Such a horrible way to die, anyway.....

Score: 4

Jan N Andy Oakley-Hills

11:49am on 17/9/2012

Such a terrible tragedy, but too frequent on farms with slurry tanks, so where is Health and Safety when it is really needed? Some drastic steps need to be taken to stop this ever happening again. Hopefully the sister will recover soon, and condolences to all the rest of the family.

Score: 1
Advertisement