UK & World News
Mantel's Speech On Duchess Causes A Storm
Hilary Mantel has caused a furore after giving a speech in which she appeared to criticise the Duchess of Cambridge.
The Daily Mail ran a front-page article hitting out at the two-times Booker Prize winner for her "venomous attack" on the former Kate Middleton.
In a speech earlier this month, Mantel said she saw Prince William's wife becoming a "jointed doll on which certain rags were hung ... a shop-window mannequin".
Mantel said that as a royal consort, Kate "appeared to have been designed by committee and built by craftsmen, with a perfect plastic smile and the spindles of her limbs hand-turned and gloss-varnished".
Even David Cameron - who is on a trip to India - commented about the affair, saying Mantel's comments were "completely misguided and completely wrong".
But the author's remarks, which were reprinted this week in the London Review Of Books, seem to have been taken out of context.
Her speech was about the British public's complex relationship with royalty over the centuries - a relationship both symbiotic and voyeuristic.
It looked at the way the public and the press glorify and destroy royals, from Anne Boleyn to Diana, Princess of Wales, casting them in roles and stories in which "adulation can swing to persecution within hours".
Nevertheless, the Daily Mail labelled it an "astonishing and venomous attack" on Kate.
It quoted Mantel's speech at length, although it did not point out that Mantel was describing what she saw as a view of Kate constructed by the press and public opinion.
In her speech, Mantel said Diana "passed through trials, through ordeals at the world's hands".
She also said Prince Harry "doesn't know which he is, a person or a prince" - a confusion on which Harry himself recently remarked.
And she said Kate, whose first child is due in July, finds herself cast by the press as someone whose "only point and purpose (is) to give birth".
Mantel ended her speech with a plea for people to "back off and not be brutes".
The speech - and its subsequent reporting - were quick to draw comments on social media.
One user tweeted: "You have to admire the genius of the Daily Mail in turning Hilary Mantel's attack on them into an attack on the Duchess of Cambridge."
Sixty-year-old Mantel won the prestigious Booker Prize in 2009 and 2012 for Wolf Hall and Bring Up The Bodies.
The novels are set in the time of King Henry VIII, focusing on the King's search for a queen who will give him a male heir.
what do you think?
Who is this Mantel woman?
Read the story and find out.
What a sour nasty ugly fat faced attention seeker - off to the chopping block with you me thinks
i'm sure mantels comments were taken out of context, a little bit like the following from myself. "mantel is a women of a certain age and, some might say, extremely ugly. it is with these shortcomings in her life that she tries to hide behind interlect and rubbish anybody lucky enough not only to be youthful but also to be gifted with natural beauty both physically and in spirit." no doubt some will interpret this, if taken out of context, as a slight towards mantel
I very much doubt she'd say that in Anne Boleyn's day :)
Just the kind of comment you'd expect from a post-menopausal 'has-been' with a ginger, home hair dye.
Old bag she's just jealous cos she's. Old and ugly
Charlotte Jane Sargent
She is all plastic!! She's trying to be the next Diana, its all for show!!
Pretty much spot on.
Not a lot more to add, hit the nail on the head!
Hmmm, maybe a little jealous of Kates good looks, methinks. With a kipper like Hilarys', i'd stick to writing books, and stay away from any TV work. She does have a point, but we don't need to hear it from her. Kate may just be a clothes horse, but at least she is injecting some good looking genes into the pool of Royal ugliness. Anyway, bring on the republic.
Try writing another book Hilary, you won`t be able to sell the film rights of what you think of Kate.
Media feeding the green eyed monster?
Hilary mantel looks like a man, hence probs why she wo. the man broker prize. But I gotta agree with her analogies of princess kate and Diana. She is spot on. They are just clothes horses bred for kids with very little personality.
The self important on the unimportant.
I was unaware that Kate had done anything to offend or harm Ms Mantel - who sounds like guest you don't invite twice.
nothing like flushing your carreir down the toilet
Lets face it I have listened to this woman and she should change her name from Mantel to MENTAL She received a bit of fame with the Booker prize and the limelight as gone to her head
This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.
As a guy I know which one would win in a glamour contest - another pretender trying to make a name for herself