Financial News

  • 4 February 2013, 8:42

Horse DNA: Burger King Dumps Irish Supplier

Burger King has issued full page newspaper apologies after discovering horse DNA in beefburgers from its supplier in Ireland.

The fast food chain said sorry to customers as it confirmed it was cutting ties with Silvercrest, the food processing plant that supplied contaminated burgers to UK supermarkets.

Burger King said its own tests for equine DNA in its burgers had come back negative and that four samples from the Silvercrest plant that did test positive were from a product that did not make it into restaurants.

The Miami-based chain said the failure to deliver 100% British and Irish beef patties was a violation of contracts.

The UK newspaper ads include a statement from Diego Beamonte, Burger King Corporation's vice president for global quality, who said: "While the Food Safety Authority of Ireland has stated that this is not a food safety issue, we are deeply troubled by the findings of our investigation and apologise to our guests, who trust us to source only the highest quality 100% beef burgers.

"Our supplier has failed us and in turn we have failed you. We are committed to ensuring that this does not happen again."

The Irish authorities said that their investigations had traced filler product used in the burger processing facility to a supplier in Poland.

It contained a mixture of beef and horse off-cuts.

Experts from the Food Standards Agency (FSA) yesterday told the Commons Environment Committee that they could not be sure whether the contaminated burgers were being sold for more than a year.

Bosses at the Food Safety Authority of Ireland (FSAI), who identified and publicised the controversy, and Department of Agriculture chiefs have yet to be questioned at a similar level in Dublin.

At least 10 million burgers were put into storage following the scandal. Silvercrest's parent company ABP Food Group initially said they would be destroyed.

Silvercrest had a contract to supply Burger King in the UK, Ireland and Denmark. It is understood the deals with the fast food chain and Tesco were worth in the region of £39m.

The Ballybay processing factory, closed since the scandal broke two weeks ago, employed 112 people.

Burger King said it had carried out its own internal investigation including scientific tests, inspection of the Silvercrest facility and scrutiny of traceability records over the last fortnight.

It has been using approved suppliers from Germany and Italy as a precaution since.

Burger King's apology came after Aldi suspended its contract with beefburger supplier Dalepak, having found small traces of horsemeat DNA in its products.

The supermarket withdrew three beefburger lines earlier this month after traces of pig meat and horsemeat were discovered, and launched an investigation.

"Aldi UK's customers are our absolute priority," a spokesman said. "This is why we immediately withdrew these products until such a time that we could verify that there was no risk to our customers.

"We are deeply angry and feel let down by our supplier and we are pursuing more tests until we are certain that we understand how the production line was contaminated."

what do you think?

18 comments

marc H

9:09am on 1/2/2013

wtf is all this fuss about? the french have been eating horsemeat for centuries. Ive eaten horse meat and its very tasty. A cow is prettier than a horse so dont give me the rubbish about cuteness. At the moment we have a choice but I wonder how many of these 'I wont eat horse flesh' people would still say that if horse flesh was the only accessible meat? I rest my case.

Score: 22
7 replies

Brian Holmes

9:36am on 1/2/2013

Let's add a few witchety grubs in there as well.

Score: 8

movvi

10:53pm on 1/2/2013

I think it's more about getting what you ask or pay for. If you bought a sealed pack of beef, for example, to find it was actually squirrel, it wouldn't half spoil your plans for a Wellington! I giggled at your pretty cows!

Score: 10

endofastorm

8:25am on 2/2/2013

The suppliers breached their contract and in doing so deceived Burger King, the retail outlets and the public. I'd be very unhappy too. If I was being conned for my £39million. The contract was to supply 100 % British beef - so fillers and traces of pork and horsemeat including some from Poland don't count.

Score: 6

Chris Price

12:58pm on 2/2/2013

Meats meat at the end of the day if food suddenly went scarce due to a break down in our ecosystem. Then cow or horse im not fussed. Ive already got a few ideas for the neighbours five cats just in case.....

Score: 6

chrishearn350

9:43am on 3/2/2013

The French have been eating frogs and snails but I wouldn't want them in a burger labeled Beef ! Maybe they should try labeling them as "Horse and other meat burgers"

Score: 2

chrishearn350

9:46am on 3/2/2013

Brian I would think there's a few grubs in them already. I found a maggot in a Scotch egg once, It was the only recognisable meat in it ! Lovely Grub

Score: 3

Chris Price

1:02pm on 3/2/2013

Doner kebab meat, Has it ever been part of an animal? Does anyone ever question what goes in it? Do we ever find out? Will we ever find out?

Score: 2

davenlesley

9:23am on 1/2/2013

Marc. I agree with you that eating horsemeat is something which is done around the world without causing harm. But that is not the issue here. This stuff was sold as 100% British/Irish BEEF which it was not. Food packaging has a list of contents as long as you arm with every E ingredient right down to the last pinch of salt. It is a trust issue and we were lied to. If I buy a bag of sugar I don't want to find it contains salt.. There could also be allergy issues involved as well.

Score: 19
7 replies

marc H

10:33am on 1/2/2013

point taken m8

Score: 8

Gordon Wright

10:34am on 1/2/2013

Quite right Dave, We need to know exactly what is in the food we eat. I have type 2 diabetes and of course horsemeat will not affect me in the slightest. It is essential however, that I know what my food contains since other "unknown" substances could be added if suppliers are allowed to get away with this sort of thing. This is a question of public trust............

Score: 7

Juliecrumpton1234

7:57pm on 1/2/2013

Agree dave, it's not poisonous, it comes down to dishonesty, I'm not a meat lover, but if I was, I would prefer to know what I was eating!

Score: 6

movvi

10:50pm on 1/2/2013

Agreed. I said something similar a few days ago. I've never had a burger and don't eat flesh but a line has to be drawn because it's the principle of the thing, isn't it? Otherwise, human and penguin and all sorts could be finding their way into our food and I think then we WOULD be worried. If I buy beef, I expect it to be beef. I can't see my man being impressed if I served him rat lasagne if he was expecting a beef one!

Score: 7

movvi

10:54pm on 1/2/2013

And hello, Julie - hope you're doing well and feeling better xxx

Score: 5

davenlesley

11:53pm on 1/2/2013

Hi Julie. I wasn't expecting you back so soon. I hope everything went well and that you are feeling much better.

Score: 4

bjnk

12:02am on 2/2/2013

dave, I don't think we can trust any of these big companies,they deliberatly mislead us with ad's knowing full well its not true. They all should be taken to court and prosecuted.

Score: 5

Brian Holmes

9:38am on 1/2/2013

Burger King claim their burgers are 100% British and Irish beef yet the horse DNA apparently came in "filler" product from Poland.

Score: 10
1 reply

chrishearn350

11:24pm on 1/2/2013

Was that filler or filly !

Score: 6

Ged Sanderson

10:02am on 1/2/2013

I don't understand how beef imported to Ireland or Britain and then processed into burgers or anything else for that matter can be classed as 100% British or Irish if the animal was not bred and slaughtered in Britain.

Score: 8
2 replies

pjbeckett

11:39am on 1/2/2013

You`re not supposed to understand it. this is the multi-cutural, multi-national age

Score: 5

Chris Price

1:06pm on 3/2/2013

Calfs born in east anglia, raised in ulanbator,slaughtered in adalaide, processed and packaged in chinese taipai sold in london 100%british beef

jones.emyr

12:25pm on 1/2/2013

Well, every Burger I`ve had from Burger King has been delicious. Dont know if it had a spot of horse in there or not, but with a spot of mayo and barbecue sauce, I wouldn`t even care. Large fries with that please.

Score: 14
2 replies

movvi

10:47pm on 1/2/2013

You are a bad egg! Get me those little breaded melty cheese things and it's a date! x

Score: 5

chrishearn350

9:37am on 3/2/2013

You should try it with horse radish !

Score: 1

andrew

12:23am on 2/2/2013

95% of people are fed up with jokes about horsemeat in burgers (according to a gallop poll)

Score: 10
2 replies

movvi

6:09pm on 2/2/2013

Ha!

Score: 3

chrishearn350

9:38am on 3/2/2013

Its just a bit of horse play !

Score: 2

liam hoy

7:47am on 2/2/2013

Horse DNA aint all that bad. They found human DNA in mcflurrys at our local maccy dees!!!!

Score: 6
5 replies

Chris Price

3:46pm on 2/2/2013

Full of protein?

Score: 4

movvi

6:08pm on 2/2/2013

Hmmm, apparently likewise in the mayo at a McDonald's near here. Could this be an urban myth? I really do hope so! Bleurrgh.

Score: 2

Lorgar Aurelian

8:49pm on 2/2/2013

McD's employ humans?

Score: 4

Chris Price

1:21pm on 3/2/2013

I think lorgar the McD's employee is the missing link between austriolopithicus and the neanderthal. It was fecal matter in the milk shakes by us or at least in near-by birmingham back in the early 90s So i think it is an urban myth. Although they have found half a mouse, nematode worms and cysts in their products in the past which have been varified.

Lorgar Aurelian

3:18am on 4/2/2013

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Name witheld

12:31pm on 2/2/2013

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

stevie may

12:51pm on 2/2/2013

There's so much money to be made in meat production/distribution and big corporate companies only care about profit. Best way to avoid contaminated meat is not to eat processed meat products. Make your own pasties, sausage rolls and burgers at home. . Not difficult to do

Score: 11

Adj Jackson

2:54pm on 2/2/2013

At Piccadilly station last week a sign at BK said only chicken products were being cooked Due to faulty EQUIPMENT lol I asked the manager was the equipment thats faulty!! The piece that starts the 3.30 at Aintree

Score: 8
1 reply

chrishearn350

9:49am on 3/2/2013

Did they say The Piccafilly special burger was off tonight ?

Score: 2

Jo James

3:51pm on 2/2/2013

I'm not surprised. Who knows what you are eating in fast food places. People eat there because they are cheap. chavvy and cheap

Score: 8

Jasmin Louise

5:11pm on 2/2/2013

I don't eat meat, however I make my own burgers for family. 2Ib of minced beef. 1 small onion (finely chopped) 2 teaspoons sambal oelek (red chilli from jar) 1 teaspoon paprika, 2 teaspoons oregano, salt and freshly ground pepper...mix all together. Fry on each side using olive oil. Serve with freshly prepared salad in crusty rolls or sesame buns....GET COOKING ;)

Score: 6
3 replies

Lorgar Aurelian

8:50pm on 2/2/2013

How do you bind it all together?

Score: 3

Jasmin Louise

10:02pm on 2/2/2013

Hello Lorgar.just mix everything together in a bowl using your hands. The trick is to use ordinary mince (not lean) the additional fat will keep it together....

Score: 2

Steve

9:25am on 3/2/2013

I add a beaten egg myself,works wonders.

Score: 2

TIM x

8:37pm on 2/2/2013

Horseburger king! All they need is a rebrand!

Score: 5

Paul Croxton

11:59pm on 2/2/2013

I think u would find these supermarkets and burger chains try to bully these suppliers into lower prices so these suppliers find alternatives that are cheaper I don't think its right what's happened but u are only hearing part of this story lets see if any supermarket orburger chain will admit they demanded lower prices no because they want to look good to the public

Score: 5
1 reply

davenlesley

10:20am on 3/2/2013

Paul. Sound comments my friend. Lets not think that the supermarkets are the wronged party in this because thye aint.As you rightly say the less they pay suppliers for products the bigger their profits

Score: 3

Trence Scott

12:01am on 3/2/2013

next time someone wants to feed their family steak and chips, they should ask tesco and the likes to stock their shelves with stakes of the horsemeat variety.

Score: 3

chrishearn350

10:22am on 3/2/2013

he Miami-based chain said the failure to deliver 100% British and Irish beef patties was a violation of contracts. Had a burger King burger or Tesco's ? Lets get suing when you buy a beef burger if it says BEEF you Should get BEEF !

Score: 2
1 reply

Paul Croxton

6:17pm on 3/2/2013

In fact its a violation of trades description if the packaging says burger any meat can go I'n the product as soon as u say 100% beef no other meat may go in the product oh its a 5000 pound fine per item so these supermarkets should be fined its there responsibility to keep track of there products they sell prooves my point they care only for profit not the consumer or supplier

Score: 4

arthur ruddock

7:03am on 4/2/2013

A few years back we all the fuss about cjd. Since then passporting of all animals entering the food chain has been tightened up. Horses are not bred in this country or farmed for meat. Most are leisure animals which have in their lifetime been injected with substances which should by law prevent them from entering the food chain. The passport system for horses is so corrupt that many of the horses slaughtered in this country and then sold abroad will have also been injected during their lifetime with god knows what. I personally don t want to eat horse meat..thats my personal choice and i am entitled to know when it is in any product.

Score: 3

barry simms

9:56am on 4/2/2013

Go in to each retail with a written WARNING and inform them you will return to conduct a FULL INSPECTION , to chech Lab facilities and records of DATES checks made , GET HEALTH & SAFETY of their CHAIRS as we the Public hear so much of the Banging on about Health & Safety WHEN ITS SUITS , the those in Breech fine them how much do Tescos & others make in the UK!!!!!!!!!! get back on it not 3 days a week but five (5). theres plenty looking for 5 day work right >

Score: 1
Advertisement