Financial News

  • 13 February 2013, 22:29

Horsemeat: Call For EU Tests As Plants Raided

Those guilty of passing off horsemeat as beef are being threatened with the "full force of the law" after two British processing plants were shut down following raids.

The warning came from Environment Secretary Owen Paterson, who is in Brussels for a summit of EU leaders on the widening scandal.

The European Commission is now urging governments to carry out DNA tests on processed beef to check for contamination by horsemeat, starting in March.

There should also be tests for the presence of the veterinary painkiller known as "bute", which is causes cancer in humans and is banned from the food chain, European health commissioner Tonio Borg said.

The problem was being treated as a fraud issue rather than one of food safety, he said.

Earlier the Food Standards Agency (FSA) and police swooped on a slaughterhouse and a meat manufacturer after apparently uncovering "a blatant misleading of consumers".

Peter Boddy slaughterhouse in Todmorden, West Yorkshire, and meat processing plant Farmbox Meats in Llandre near Aberystwyth, West Wales, had records seized and have been temporarily closed. The firms' owners deny any wrongdoing.

At Farmbox Meats, Sky News saw large crates of meat - some covered by tarpaulin and others open - left in outdoor areas during the night, before they were removed this morning.

Its owner, Dafydd Ffredric Raw-Rees, told Sky News no meat had been seized and said the plant was operating as normal. The FSA later confirmed it should not be.

Slaughterhouse owner Peter Boddy said he would co-operate with FSA officers.

The FSA, which is investigating claims the firms supplied and used horse carcasses in burgers and kebabs, says it has "detained" all meat found at both premises and seized paperwork.

Mr Paterson said: "It's totally unacceptable if any business in the UK is defrauding the public by passing off horsemeat as beef.

"I expect the full force of the law to be brought down on anyone involved in this kind of activity."

David Cameron, speaking at PMQs, described the situation as "appalling" and "completely unacceptable".

"If there has been criminal activity, there should be the full intervention of the law," the Prime Minister said.

Until now, meat linked to the scandal had been thought to have come from suppliers in continental Europe, but for the first time it appears the contamination may also come from British premises.

Andrew Rhodes, FSA director of operations, said: "I ordered an audit of all horse producing abattoirs in the UK after this issue first arose last month and I was shocked to uncover what appears to be a blatant misleading of consumers.

"I have suspended both plants immediately while our investigations continue."

Mr Paterson has met representatives of the Institute of Grocery Distribution, which represents food retailers and suppliers, to discuss plans for a new regime of quarterly testing of products.

Results of tests into the extent of contamination of beef products are expected on Friday.

Meanwhile, Waitrose announced it has withdrawn its beef Essential British Frozen Meatballs after pork was found in two batches. The supermarket said they were made at the ABP Foods-owned Freshlink factory in Glasgow last summer.

Tesco has become the latest retailer to drop a major supplier after discovering a range of spaghetti bolognese ready meals contained more than 60% horsemeat.

Morrisons chief executive Dalton Philips has told Sky's Jeff Randall the chain could not be 100% sure about the content of all of its beef products either, but he said its checks are rigorous and it has "extremely high" confidence.

As the scandal widens in Europe, Norway has pulled imported Findus beef products thought to contain horsemeat from shelves.

Ministers from the worst-affected EU nations were meeting in Brussels to discuss their response to the scandal, which erupted after tests in Ireland showed products labelled as beef contained up to 100% horsemeat.

Concerns have been raised that horsemeat sometimes contains the painkiller bute, which causes cancer in humans and is banned from the human food chain.

what do you think?

18 comments

field_pete

8:56am on 13/2/2013

I've got trays of Tesco's minced beef and Tesco's meatballs in the freezer, sausages as well. Now, I'm not against eating horsemeat but I'd like to have the choice. These items state quite clearly what should be in them, but if they have an ingredient that isn't on the label then there is a clear problem. Also, what about corned beef, Fray Bentos pies, anyones pies for that matter, any frozen ready meal. It is basic honesty, the consumer has been well and truly shafted once again.

Score: 20
1 reply

Adrian Wagstaff

1:13pm on 13/2/2013

Just ignore everyone and eat all those. It's very unlikely to be horse meat. If it is, it doesn't matter. Corned beef? I noticed, in a tin, in a shop, corned beef contains cooked AND uncooked beef. I was wondering why that is. Think it was 12% uncooked beef. Why would they store cooked beef with 12% uncooked? I think, you spent a lot of money on all that food, so there is no point waisting it or worrying if it contains any horses. Try an armadillo or ostrich burger.

Score: 15

keith

9:09am on 13/2/2013

Oh come on, huge profits to be made, usually very little chance of being caught by anybody, they have only found out because somebody has not been aid along the line somewhere and they have squealed. You think its only horses????, if you only knew what you do eat..........................

Score: 13

Phil A

10:29am on 13/2/2013

"I expect the full force of the law to be brought down on anyone involved in this kind of activity.". So we can look forward to all the Supermarkets involved being prosecuted then?

Score: 15
6 replies

Vincent Stafford

12:34pm on 13/2/2013

Spot on Phil A - we all know too well that "the full force of the law " means something entirely different when applied to large organisations and companies as opposed to us plebs.As you rightly suggest the suppliers , processors and retailers must be scared stiff - not !!

Score: 7

rebel0931

1:48pm on 13/2/2013

Why do people presume that supermarkets know what ingredients are in the products they sell? Where do you draw the line of responsibility? The meat suppliers? The processors? The processed food distributors? The manufacturers of the finished product? The supermarkets? Why not warehouse staff, shelf fillers, cashiers? Anyone who handles the finished product believes what they read on the packet as to ingredients, this includes supermarkets. Someone somewhere along the line has fiddled, not necessarily the supermarkets.

Score: 9

shaun spencer

2:32pm on 13/2/2013

Cant really blame the supermarlets as theyve been duped is well, its obviously suppliers somewhere.

Score: 7

Phil A

3:23pm on 13/2/2013

The Supermarkets themselves have admitted it is their ultimate responsibility to ensure the food they sell is as described on the packet. As to being duped-I believe they are at least complicit in this scandal - they knew it was happening and kept quiet, or worse still are actively involved.

Score: 4

shirley sutton

4:14pm on 13/2/2013

The supermarkets can only go by what they're told and what's on the labels same as us they don't pack the stuff they just sell it

Score: 6

Andy Smithies

5:20pm on 13/2/2013

The supermarkeys have there own labs to test dont they?? YES THEY DO!! So why are they not as res[ponsible as the supplier??

Score: 3

Brian Holmes

1:59pm on 13/2/2013

Full force of the law? They can't even ban them!

Score: 9

shirley sutton

4:11pm on 13/2/2013

Why was FSA doing its job and inspecting these places - funny they suddenly checked after all this blew up isn't it?

Score: 9
1 reply

Lorgar Aurelian

4:56pm on 13/2/2013

Like any government department, they shut the door once the horse has bolted...

Score: 5

johnjbbailey

4:19pm on 13/2/2013

I think that Horse meat may be the way to go, less chance of catching Mad Cow from a horse......... An how come i am now johnjbbailey when i should be DAVE FLY THE UNION FLAG BROWN?

Score: 9

Mike Anon

5:19pm on 13/2/2013

Anyone remember the TV series "The Galloping Gourmet"? Perhaps he knew something we didn't?

Score: 8

Andy Sillitoe

6:11pm on 13/2/2013

All this horse meat will give you the trots

Score: 6

sunshine

6:38pm on 13/2/2013

Now who was it set up the FSA? Let me think!!!

Score: 4

Name witheld

6:48pm on 13/2/2013

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 4

happymike CHESTER

7:20pm on 13/2/2013

Getting bored with this now a good story to bury bad Tory/Lib/Dem news like stealing more money off pensioners, Accountants running bad hospitals Bank of England printing money ect.ect.ect.

Score: 9

david

7:20pm on 13/2/2013

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Howard Kingsbury

8:35pm on 13/2/2013

Imagine the consternation. Consignment from Brasov. Tests 75% human.

Score: 4

chrishearn350

9:41pm on 13/2/2013

"full force of the law" just like the bankers then!!!

Score: 4

stevegs850

10:08pm on 13/2/2013

is this what they call bolting the stable door after the horse has bolted

Score: 3

chrishearn350

10:36pm on 13/2/2013

Do the FSA do anything for their £100 million a year budget ?! maybe a little random testing . How many casualty animals are ending up in the food chain ? and that would be beef very hard to detect amongst all that Horse and other"?" meat ! Still look on the bright side Its all for Profit !

Score: 3

chrishearn350

6:47pm on 14/2/2013

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Eric Clutterbean

7:02pm on 14/2/2013

i wonder now if my fish fingers are 100 % seahorse

Score: 1
Advertisement