UK & World News

  • 17 July 2012, 16:11

Killer Shot Indian Student 'For Notoriety'

A psychologist has suggested that killer Kiaran Stapleton shot an innocent student to enhance his own reputation.

Dr Adrian West interviewed Stapleton following the killing. He told a jury that the defendant might have carried a gun to achieve some form of notoriety.

"Gun-related violence can be seen as a means of re-affirming identity and masculinity," he said.

Stapleton admits manslaughter but denies murdering Anuj Bidve on the grounds of diminished responsibility. The Lancaster University student was on his way with a group of friends to Boxing Day sales in Manchester last year.

Dr West said he did not consider the defendant to have learning difficulties and that at the time of the shooting he had a "clear mental state" and was able to make rational judgements.

The jury have already heard that Stapleton attacked a fellow inmate at HMP Manchester with a bucket of hot water laced with melted sugar so it would stick to the victim's skin.

Dr West said that following the assault, Stapleton said: "I am in here for murder not shoplifting. Guys see me differently now. Kept to myself before. Now they respect me. Guards are more concerned. They say I am unpredictable."

Experts have been discussing Kiaran Stapleton's mental state in the moments leading up to the death of 23-year-old Mr Bidve.

Dr West, called by the prosecution to give evidence, said that in approaching the victim and his friends "various witnesses describe him as not loud, not aggressive, casual indeed, walking in a hip-hop style.

"Mr Stapleton, seeing the group of students, was aware that they represented no imminent threat nor that there was any account of provocation towards him."

The trial continues.

what do you think?

11 comments

speller007

1:34pm on 17/7/2012

as his shot the student, in order to make a name for himself. and was of sound mind at the time, shoot him and send a clear message an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth. why should the tax payer have to fund his incarceration for a mindless act of violence?

Score: 8
3 replies

TIM x

2:09pm on 17/7/2012

Well said! We now have to fund his play station and tv and 3 square meals a day. No doubt the liberals will want to send him on holiday. Lets see what a man he is stood in front of the gallows. This is not about revenge this is justice.

Score: 7

Name witheld

2:51pm on 17/7/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

Name witheld

3:20pm on 17/7/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

fish41

3:45pm on 17/7/2012

Perhaps stoning has a place in civilised society after all

Score: 1

Michael Dynes

3:49pm on 17/7/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

ronniewood99

4:36pm on 17/7/2012

what a clown !! he will soon learn not to play the big I am when he meets up with some of the real hard men of the clink ,then he will wish he had never been born ,take him away

Score: 7

Phylip de la Maziere

4:48pm on 17/7/2012

Looks a right "nutter" must be a united fan

Score: 2

aa aa

5:06pm on 17/7/2012

A wasted life of an innocent young man. Someone who was trying to better himself by studying. Then along comes this numbskull.What are we going to do about his type, absolutely nothing. He'll do about seven years, then he'll hurt or kill someone else, and we'll try to learn what's in his mind, and so on and..... Best thing to do , is lethal injection. Something that will deter others. Not seven years of reputation building, and free gymnasium, and free playstation, etc. The anti hanging brigade brought this on.

Score: 5

aa aa

5:07pm on 17/7/2012

Oh dear. just read it again, and he's a Manc. Says it all, really.

Score: 5

Mick Daniel

5:11pm on 17/7/2012

For 'notoriety', we should hang him

Score: 3

Name witheld

5:25pm on 17/7/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Paul Walsh

5:40pm on 17/7/2012

This is where capital punishment should be returned! No doubts, no ifs or buts, he deliberately murdered another honest, law-abiding person just to get a reputation! However the liberals wont contemplate it, so lock him up for 99 years as a minimum sentence, before parole can be considered! Lets see his reputation then!!!

Score: 1

Thomas Cat

5:42pm on 17/7/2012

I feel desperately sorry for Anuj Bidve's parents.To lose a son in any circumstances is bad enough, but to lose a son in such a dreadful manner,far away from home must be horrendous. They acted with great dignity throughout the trial and deserve our thoughts and prayers.

Score: 7
1 reply

dave

10:08pm on 17/7/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Advertisement