UK & World News

  • 19 September 2012, 3:44

Nato Scales Back Links With Afghan Forces

Defence Secretary Philip Hammond has insisted British operations in Afghanistan will not be affected by Nato's scaling down of joint patrols with native forces.

Nato has decided that any joint patrols and advisory work with Afghan troops smaller than battalion level will now have to be approved by regional commanders.

The temporary decision by the International Security Assistance Force (Isaf) follows a string of "green on blue" attacks by Afghan soldiers and police.

It also comes against the backdrop of an upsurge in protests linked to the anti-Islam film Innocence of Muslims and emerged hours after a suicide bomber struck in Kabul.

Amid confusion over how the order would affect soldiers on the ground and the withdrawal due in 2014, Conservative MP John Baron tabled an urgent question.

Mr Hammond therefore had to appear before MPs to give assurances about Afghan strategy for the second time in less than 24 hours, after appearing on Monday to discuss Afghan security.

He insisted that the Isaf commander in charge of the Helmand region where most UK troops are based had confirmed he is happy for British mentoring and partnering operations to continue at below battalion level.

"That means that the UK partnering and mentoring operations will continue substantially unchanged by this order," he told MPs.

However, Mr Baron - a former Army captain - said: "This announcement threatens to blow a hole in our stated exit strategy."

He added: "This announcement adds to the uncertainty as to whether Afghan forces will have the ability to keep an undefeated Taliban at bay once Nato forces have left."

Labour MP Paul Flynn was expelled from the Commons for a day after accusing defence ministers of "lying" over Afghan policy and refusing to withdraw the comment.

The restriction on troops' activities was issued by the second most senior US commander in Afghanistan, Lieutenant-General James Terry.

Senior Nato spokesman US Colonel Tim Collins said it was only a "temporary and prudent response" to the current threat of insider attacks and the mounting anger in the Muslim world over a film mocking the Prophet Mohammad.

Afghan commanders were not told of the order until a hurried meeting on Tuesday and it appeared to take Britain and other coalition members by surprise.

Mr Hammond told MPs it was issued on Sunday evening and he was informed at a meeting on Monday, after his first Commons statement.  

He insisted "no particular significance was attached to it" but Sky's defence and security editor Sam Kiley said: "This is a very significant tactical shift in approach."

The decision follows the deaths of six foreign soldiers were killed over the weekend in southern Afghanistan where the Taliban have the most support.

They included two British soldiers who died when they were attacked by a man dressed as an Afghan policeman feigning injury.

Labour MP Denis MacShane said the change amounted to a reversal of the US and UK strategy but Mr Hammond said: "We have got a strategic plan. We are working towards an end to our combat operations in 2014.

"We have said all along we will take every step that we need to take to minimise the risk to our troops and that is what we are doing.

"There will be lots of measures that Isaf is taking over the next days and weeks to minimise the risk to our forces and I welcome them all."

Foreign Secretary William Hague agreed, saying: "There is no change in strategy and I think the impact of the Isaf announcement will be quite minimal on UK operations."

The Chief of Defence Staff, General Sir David Richards, told Sky News: "There is no change in strategy. How we implement the strategy is always under review."

US Defence Secretary Leon Panetta, speaking in Beijing, admitted that the US was concerned about insider attacks but insisted the plan to hand over security by 2014 was unchanged.

More than 30 such attacks have claimed the lives of 51 troops in the Nato-led coalition so far this year, sowing mistrust between the Western force and its nominal allies.

This represents a spike of more than 40% on similar incidents for the whole of last year.

Commanders believe only a quarter of the assaults are the result of infiltration by Taliban insurgents and that the remainder were caused by cultural clashes and personal grievances.

Afghanistan's defence ministry said earlier this month that it had arrested or sacked hundreds of Afghan soldiers for suspected insurgency links.

September 18: Nine Killed In Kabul Minibus Suicide Attack

September 17: Brit Soldiers Killed By Rogue Afghan Policeman

Update:

Hello, regular commenting on Orange News and Sport pages closes on Thursday 30 May 2013. We will continue to provide a commenting facility on major news and sport events on orangeworld.co.uk. Contact us via http://oran.ge/OWfeedback if you have any further questions. Thanks.

what do you think?

12 comments

Name witheld

5:23am on 18/9/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 5
2 replies

faiq mir

5:43am on 18/9/2012

whats even more weird is dat only quarter were taliban....the rest had personal or cultural problems....so 39 soliders were killed thru differences...hmmmm

Score: 1

Robin Van Der Spiegel

6:19am on 18/9/2012

Don't worry I'm sure he isn't

doug piercy

6:07am on 18/9/2012

PH is the co pilot/gunner !

Score: 4

Michael Mcardle

9:03am on 18/9/2012

great news now howabout we scale back relations with the whole god forsaken country7 and bring all western troops put and leave them to sort their own problems out. they dont want us there interfering . they have made it quite obvious time and again. give them what they want and get out

Score: 13

ali baba

10:11am on 18/9/2012

Afghanistan a country of simple villagers who just wanna get by. Decades of super powers ( USA and USSR ) trying to stamp there mark. WhAt have these people done to deserve this?

Score: 16
4 replies

Michael Mcardle

3:41pm on 18/9/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

blue side

4:28pm on 18/9/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

blue side

8:31pm on 18/9/2012

Would Orange please tell me why my comments were removed? There was absolutely nothing controversial just fact about drugs and the Russians warning us. Am beginning to think Orang or Google has a real problem

Score: 4

Jim Mills

9:39am on 19/9/2012

I'm with you blueside

Score: 1

gengisken1227

11:26am on 18/9/2012

Get our troops out of Afghanistan now and reset their watches from the 13th centuary

Score: 10

gypsy56

12:16pm on 18/9/2012

Perhaps a group of MP's could fly over there and do some frontline patrols with the troops to see for themselves if anything more could be done to minimise the risk! After all they all line up to go on overseas jaunts to see how over countries deal with things like student protesters, strikers. the homeless, even gambling laws. Being a soldier on the frontline is one of the biggest gambles anyone can do, especially when it's in somebody elses country and for somebody elses cause! At one point you had to become a mercenary to do that; is that what these politicians have done to the British armed forces - are they now simply soldiers for hire ? Available to the highest bidder- whatever the cause, whatever the cost!

Score: 7
1 reply

Lorgar Aurelian

2:29pm on 18/9/2012

Very good comment. Though i must say, mercenaries are generally better equipped than the average British Tom!

Score: 7

Stuart Harley

1:08pm on 18/9/2012

.I ALWAYS THOUGHT WE WERE THERE TO HELP THEM INTRODUCE DEMOCRACY ......... BUT I THINK WE ARE WASTING LIVES, TIME, AND MONEY ON THESE PEOPLE, THEY DO NOT WANT THE WESTS HELP......SO WE MUST GET OUT AND LET THEM GET ON WITH IT, AND NO HANDOUTS EITHER !!

Score: 8
1 reply

Istiak Stealth Khan

10:51am on 19/9/2012

Mmmmm..im afraid your wrong there Stuart! Your governments were there for various reasons and one of the main reason is for the abundant gas reserves that your governments have started selling/contracting to India and China. Democracy and peace is not achieved by the point of a gun and by sending armies and missiles into that country. It contradicts the whole notion of peace. You are right on one thing..you are wasting the Afghan lives..you are robbing/wasting their money(natural resources) and you are wasting there time as they could have been getting on with their lives.

Name witheld

1:12pm on 18/9/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

holly gardner

2:01pm on 18/9/2012

Can you blame the afghans, they are being occupied by the west, anyone would defend their country from foreign invaders. Any decent person would know that 9/11 was a inside job, so these warmongers can invade and occupy and any country they want.

Score: 14
1 reply

Jim Mills

9:38am on 19/9/2012

9/11 an inside job? Are you trying to say that the US hijacked the aircraft and crashed them into the towers? If so lady you need to get a grip on reality

Score: 1

holly gardner

2:09pm on 18/9/2012

These people are witnessing whole familes being murdered and bombed, innocent woman and children bein slaughtered.

Score: 13
3 replies

Michael Mcardle

2:52pm on 18/9/2012

yeah by their own people most of the time holly. you believe if our troops left everthing in the garden would be rosy give your head a shake youre dreaming like mr baba

Score: 10

holly gardner

4:04pm on 18/9/2012

Re; michael. well if they never invaded it would have been better than it is right now

Score: 9

Michael Mcardle

4:37pm on 18/9/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Raymond Castle

3:02pm on 18/9/2012

I've said it before and I'll say it again.......grow a backbone Mr Cameron and withdraw our troops now not in a couple of years time. These people want to live in the stone age so let them get on with it.

Score: 7

holly gardner

4:05pm on 18/9/2012

Well its not going according to plan for nato is it?

Score: 7
2 replies

Robin Van Der Spiegel

6:13pm on 18/9/2012

Much to your obvious delight eh holly

Score: 6

John Anderson

7:23pm on 18/9/2012

Yep, Robin, the black widow is back.

Score: 6
Advertisement