UK & World News

  • 1 August 2012, 3:16

China's Ye Shiwen Bags Second Gold

A Chinese swimmer whose sensational performance has raised eyebrows at the Olympics, has won her second gold medal.

Ye Shiwen, 16, swam to victory in the women's 200m individual medley with a time of 2 minutes and 57.07 seconds, beating Australia's Alicia Coutts into second place and America's Caitlin Leverenz into third.

An international row had erupted after Shiwen took five seconds off her personal best and more than a second off the world record in the 400m individual medley.

She was later cleared of using banned substances by the World Doping Agency.

John Leonard, the US executive director of the World Swimming Coaches Association, had earlier described the schoolgirl's performance as suspicious and "disturbing".

In comments that sparked rumours of doping, he branded the lightning-speed swim "unbelievable". Meanwhile, previous world record holder Steph Rice said it was "insanely fast".

As China reacted with anger to the suggestion of foul play, Ye denied taking performance-enhancing drugs and said her results come from hard work and training.

Olympic officials, other swimmers and former athletes also hit back, insisting that any competitor should be considered innocent until proven guilty.

British Olympic Association chairman Lord Moynihan said: "We know how on top of the game Wada (World Anti-Doping Agency) are and Wada have passed her as clean. That's the end of the story.

"And it is regrettable there is so much speculation out there. I don't like it. I think it is wrong. Let us recognise that there is an extraordinary swimmer out there who deserves the recognition of her talent in these Games."

Mark Adams, communications director for the International Olympic Committee (IOC) added: "These are the world's best athletes competing at the very highest level. We have seen all sorts of records broken already all over the place."

He stressed that a "very, very strong drug testing programme" was in place. "We are very confident that if there are cheats we will catch them, as we already have done," he said.

Asked if he was disappointed that talk turns to doping when a world record is smashed, he added: "It is inevitably a sad result of the fact that there are people who dope and who cheat but I equally think it's very sad if we can't applaud a great performance. Let's always give the benefit of the doubt to athletes."

Earlier, former Chinese basketball Olympian Ma Jian told Sky News that the US should not make allegations without evidence as thousands posted messages of support for Ye on China's popular microblogging site Weibo - the country's equivalent to Twitter.

"It's not classy at all to say that record-breakers have taken drugs. It's just jealousy," wrote one user. Another post said: "She's just a child. Don't be so beastly to her."

GB Olympic bronze medal winning swimmer Cassie Patten also told Sky News: "They have just branded her as a drugs cheat. It makes me very angry.

"She won the World Championships last year, she was ranked second in the world. She's not a new swimmer who has just come out of nowhere." 

Olympic triple jump gold medallist Jonathan Edwards took to Twitter to express his concern.

The former GB champion wrote: "Forgive personal reference, but my WR 17 yrs old and never been doubted. If my nationality was different?? Point: if I can, anyone can."

He added: "In a country as populous as China, untapped potential mind blowing. Ye Shiwen may simple be Beijing legacy #InspireAGeneration."

Ye herself insists the team have nothing to hide, saying: "The Chinese team keep very firmly to the anti-doping policies, so there is absolutely no problem."

Sports lawyer John Taylor told Sky News there was not much else the young athlete, who has passed all her drugs tests, could do for now.

"The conundrum is that you get too good a performance like this and credibility is suspended and people start asking questions. All she can do is produce the samples and allow them to test her. There's not really much more you can do at this stage," he said.

The controversy erupted after an interview Mr Leonard gave to The Guardian.

He said: "We want to be very careful about calling it doping. The one thing I will say is that history in our sport will tell you that every time we see something, and I will put quotation marks around this, 'unbelievable', history shows us that it turns out later on there was doping involved.

"That last 100m was reminiscent of some old East German swimmers, for people who have been around a while. It was reminiscent of 400m individual medley by a young Irish woman in Atlanta."

This was a reference to Irish swimmer Michelle Smith who was banned for four years in 1998, two years after Atlanta, after testing positive for androstenedione.

"She looks like superwoman. Any time someone has looked like superwoman in the history of our sport they have later been found guilty of doping," the US sports coach added.

what do you think?

first 20 comments

Chris Price

5:51am on 31/7/2012

Bad losers

Score: 16
1 reply

andrew

7:59am on 31/7/2012

You don'y think 5 seconds off of her PB is a bit suspicous in a sport where they usually shave off tenths of a second at best. I say innocent until proven guilty though, perhaps given her youth she had a sudden growth spurt giving her alot more strength.

Score: 13

chris

6:56am on 31/7/2012

I wonder has any of China's sporting associations ever 'banned' a competitor? Have there anti-doping agencies ever declared a positive find? Or are they working closely with the teams and coaches?

Score: 8

Mike Drouin

7:08am on 31/7/2012

As if the yanks have never used banned substancxes i realy hope it is proved this young woman is clean up yours yanks .

Score: 14

Greg Robinson

7:14am on 31/7/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

krafty81

7:25am on 31/7/2012

I suppose if she had been American they wouldn't have batted an eyelid! well done to her.. Just hope the allegations aren't true

Score: 15

thompsons

7:39am on 31/7/2012

the never do wrong yanks moaning again, whats new

Score: 13
1 reply

Tadhg Capone

10:03am on 31/7/2012

Oh so true. They are justing hating because it is one less medal for them to go home with.

Score: 8

Julie Crumpton

7:41am on 31/7/2012

Hmmm!

Score: 8

Rob Shaw

7:57am on 31/7/2012

Just sour grapes

Score: 15

Matthew Cooper

8:00am on 31/7/2012

Let us not forget not only was she strong but her swimming was perfect so maybe she has worked very hard to become the best

Score: 16

Phylip de la Maziere

8:11am on 31/7/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 9

Ben Ralph

8:15am on 31/7/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

john

8:32am on 31/7/2012

Pot calling kettle black?

Score: 8

barry

9:04am on 31/7/2012

Easy!!! Dope test just before each race along with the others and SHUT UP!!!!

Score: 8

Keith Harrison

9:04am on 31/7/2012

oh this is really in the olympic spirit of things isnt it !! if they suspect she has taken drugs to enhance performance then surly do the tests /checks before casting doubt and ultimately accusing her publicly of cheating,fair enough if she has cheated strip her of her place,but do it in a fair way you antiquated beaurocratic to ssers

Score: 7

Nick Eaton

9:13am on 31/7/2012

in circumstances like this when such a increase is noted then it should be automatic that a drug test should be carried out. If the Country has nothing to fear then they wouldnt object .If they do then ergo they must have been taking them if so then the whole country should be disquallified. That would stop them all ?and why did japan object to our second place ? ( i didnt see this so I dont know why)

Score: 8

Dave Harrison

9:34am on 31/7/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

Tadhg Capone

9:56am on 31/7/2012

Personally I believe that this young girls super performance is down to sheer discipline and hard work. The chinese people have a disciplined approach to life in all things that they do and many other nations could learn a lot from them. This girl is young, fit and healthy why is it so impossible for her to perform so well? If the officials did suspect that her performance had been enhanced then the appropriate and most cautious thing to do would be to test after the event and then if anything was established take action. It is quite disgraceful that this young girl has been exposed to the world as a cheat where no proof of doping has been presented.

Score: 12
2 replies

t.bulgin

10:06am on 31/7/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 4

Dave Harrison

10:21am on 31/7/2012

Tadhg. Agree entirely. No proof no case and we should just applaud her performance. Trouble is mud sticks

Score: 7

Dave Harrison

10:18am on 31/7/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

movvi

10:51am on 31/7/2012

I hope this kid has not been trained mercilessly until she has become freakishly fast or fed some form of performance enhancing stuff. Hardly ideal either way. The more naive me thinks it is possible to sometimes find someone who is almost super-human and that it seems unbelievable that any team would risk doping when they always seem to get caught. Today she has a Gold - go girl! - so the meanness should stop. If she is found guilty of cheating (or, rather, her representatives are), then I'm sure it'll be dealt with.

Score: 7

Windows Live User

11:00am on 31/7/2012

Is natural adrenyline a banned substance?

Score: 11
Advertisement