UK & World News

  • 14 November 2012, 21:04

Taser Death: Police Branded 'Thuggish'

Police who tackled and tasered a Brazilian student on LSD could face further action after a damning report on the man's death.

An Australian coroner said officers acted like schoolboys in "Lord Of The Flies" when they crash-tackled Roberto Laudisio Curti and shocked him with 50,000 volts.

New South Wales coroner Mary Jerram said she could not determine what caused the 21-year-old's death but added that it was "impossible to believe that he would have died but for the actions of police".

All of her recommendations were accepted by police, including that five officers involved be referred to an independent watchdog and there be an immediate review of the criteria for use of taser stun guns.

But Police Commissioner Andrew Scipione, who admitted the coroner's report was "quite scathing", said tasers would continue to be used.

"These weapons save lives," he said.

Officers pursued a shirtless Curti - who had become paranoid and was acting erratically after sharing an LSD tab with two friends - in the mistaken belief that he had committed an armed robbery on a Sydney convenience store.

In shocking him at least 14 times, tackling him to the ground and blasting him with pepper spray, the actions of a number of police officers were "reckless, careless, dangerous, and excessively forceful", Ms Jerram said.

"They were an abuse of police powers, in some instances even thuggish."

She said one probationary constable used his stun gun in a "wild and uncontrolled" manner on the Brazilian, who issued terrible screams and groans as police piled on top of him while he lay on a city street.

"A few of the other constables seem to have thrown themselves into a melee with an ungoverned pack mentality, like the schoolboys in 'Lord of the Flies'," she said, referring to the novel and film about boys who turn savage after being stranded on an island.

Ms Jerram said many of the police had "no idea what the problem was, or what threat or crime was supposedly to be averted, or concern for the value of life".

Police said Curti had shown a "superhuman" strength as he struggled against them, but the coroner said evidence from cameras on the tasers showed he was quickly handcuffed after being thrown to the ground.

She said one officer lay across his back, another knelt on him and others held his arms and legs as he was then repeatedly tasered by two officers while another sprayed pepper spray in his face.

Minutes later he was seen to be unresponsive and could not be revived.

Curti's family members welcomed the findings but said they would still be pushing for those responsible to be held accountable.

"Whilst nothing will ever bring Beto back, we continue to push for those responsible to face the consequences of their appalling behaviour on that night," family spokesman Michael Reynolds told journalists.

what do you think?

5 comments

Baker101

1:08pm on 14/11/2012

Shouldn't have been on LSD in the first place.

Score: 20
5 replies

Vanessa Lake

1:55pm on 14/11/2012

That's not the point.

Score: 15

simon calvert

3:17pm on 14/11/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

simon calvert

3:40pm on 14/11/2012

Have you got children baker? Have you read the story? Have you ever lived?

Score: 8

Nat_j2b

4:38pm on 14/11/2012

Oh well that makes it ok then I guess! What a stupid thing to say. That man did NOT deserve the treatment he was handed by the police.

Score: 9

Baker101

5:41pm on 14/11/2012

I dont remember saing it was ok...just he shouldn't have been on LSD. It's a nasty drug.

Score: 8

david

1:45pm on 14/11/2012

so we are not the only country with idiot judges..if this guy dont feel sorry for him was on on L.S.D.and out his head we may well be alive today

Score: 12
4 replies

simon calvert

3:20pm on 14/11/2012

That's a great attitude let's hope a child of yours doesn't maybe get drunk one night or take a pill or LSD,or maybe even a spliff and get tasered to death.

Score: 10

Diane Rogers

4:09pm on 14/11/2012

Simon I have said about other stories people should take responsibility for their own actions and yes I do have children 31 29 and 25 they know better

Score: 8

El Bubsio

9:26pm on 14/11/2012

And what actions is he responsible for Diane? The police's mistaken belief he'd robbed a shop, or not wearing an outfit capable of withstanding 14 taser shots, a prolonged beating and a dose of pepper spray? If he'd been drunk and acting 'erratically' would that still make all of that his fault in your eyes or is it just because it was one of those terrible terrible illegal drugs?

Score: 1

simon calvert

10:54pm on 14/11/2012

Diane, can you 100% certify none of your family have been drunk or experimented with any drug? Because if they have and were unfortunate enoughtohave wandered across these policemens path they may not be here to tell there tale. How would your holier than thou stance be then...

Score: 2

Name witheld

2:51pm on 14/11/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 10

Windows Live User

2:51pm on 14/11/2012

tasered while people were on him. Wouldnt they then be zapped as well? I remember seeing a student "take off" back in the late 60's after dropping LSD. He was unstoppable by his friends, and when he easily broke free just ran through the traffic without regard. It may well have been the case here.

Score: 8

ali baba

5:23pm on 14/11/2012

tazer on a naked man with no weapons, and many cops at the scene. totally thuggish in my eyes. he was no danger whatsoever. alot of people try a bit of weed or trips in there youth, and go on to be very successful people. not all people who do drugs are drug addicts

Score: 8
2 replies

Diane Rogers

6:18pm on 14/11/2012

Trouble is drugs affect people in different ways

Score: 4

simon calvert

10:48pm on 14/11/2012

Diane,I really dislike your blinkered point of view on this subject...supposing this Guy wasn't on drugs and was having a little mental episode, perhaps a first encounter with schizophrenia....would this change your point of view on how the police dealt with him, would that make the police action unjust then?

Score: 2
Advertisement