Financial News

  • 20 August 2012, 15:14

Supermarkets Deny Selling 'Bottled Tap Water'

Two supermarkets have denied claims the economy-price own-brand bottled water they sell is in fact tap water.

The allegations surrounded Tesco Everyday Value Still Water and Asda Smartprice Still Water, which reportedly sit on shelves alongside major mineral water brands such as Evian and Perrier.

The Daily Mail claimed the products were simply a filtered version of what is supplied to almost all domestic homes - but that there was no labelling on the bottles saying so.

It was likened to the fictional situation in the sitcom Only Fools And Horses where protagonists Del Boy and Rodney Trotter start selling "Peckham Spring", which is in fact water from the taps of their London council flat.

Both supermarkets denied misleading their customers in any way, saying the bottles gave customers a clear idea of what they were buying.

A spokeswoman for Asda, which gets its bottled water supplied by Yorkshire Water, said it was wrong to call its product tap water.

"Our Smart Price water is treated to remove chlorine, further filtered, then bottled," she said.

"If sparkling, carbon dioxide is added for a bit of fizz. The label on the bottle tells our customers just that.

"Our two-litre bottle is 17p. For comparison - if a customer bought a Brita water filter jug at £16 and used it for the recommended 40 gallons, it would cost 21p to produce two litres of filtered water.

"We're saving our customers time and money - as well as providing a container."

A spokeswoman for Tesco, whose Everyday Value Still Water also retails for 17p for two litres, said: "Our Everyday Value Still Water goes through a complex filtration process to improve the taste and remove impurities.

"Tesco sells a wide range of waters to suit all tastes and budgets. All of our products are clearly labelled so customers know what they are buying."

what do you think?

first 20 comments

Rhys Sage

1:25am on 18/8/2012

And we could get some sand filters to filter the effluent from urinals then use solar energy to blast it with UV light and then bottle that as all natural drinking water. Sure - it'd be clean and pure water but it would be taking the P just as much as the supermarkets.

Score: 11
2 replies

Martin Beadle

8:17am on 18/8/2012

thats pretty much what water is - its all second hand rhys

Score: 7

herewegoagain10

1:36pm on 18/8/2012

Seen it done and tasted it. It was so pure it was like drinking distilled water

Score: 4

Debra Wiseman

2:49am on 18/8/2012

Yeah tap water, your'e busted.

Score: 3

David Cooper

3:01am on 18/8/2012

Would not pay for water in this country unless our tap water was untreated, what a waste of money!

Score: 10
2 replies

Dave Harrison

8:49am on 18/8/2012

Quite right David. The only place I ever drink bottled water is on holiday in countries where we are told it is unsafe to drink.

Score: 8

Louise Smith

10:55am on 19/8/2012

You do pay for your tap water David

Score: 1

idandmw

6:33am on 18/8/2012

What plonkers !

Score: 5

Claire Keen

8:19am on 18/8/2012

"the peckham spring" what a classic episode:-)

Score: 12
1 reply

Jasmin Louise

8:58am on 18/8/2012

Lovely jubbly :)

Score: 7

Dave Harrison

8:42am on 18/8/2012

The provision of tap water in this country is more highly regulated than any of the bottled stuff sold in our supermarkets. It never ceases to amaze me to see folks buying gallons of the bottled version, they must have money to burn

Score: 18
9 replies

Julie Crumpton

9:07am on 18/8/2012

....it's all about image as well, dave, people think they give off this "look at me, I'm fit and workout" prefer many cups of tea, myself! Lol!

Score: 8

Dave Harrison

9:19am on 18/8/2012

Julie. You are right about the image thing. Its the same with drinking booze out of the bottle.They think it is cool but I just laugh at them The bottles have stood in a distribution yard somewhere giving the rats & cats every opportunity to pee all over them and then some cool dude drinks from them. Yuck!

Score: 9

Julie Crumpton

10:14am on 18/8/2012

Exactly, dave! :-)

Score: 5

Jo Brierley

10:50am on 18/8/2012

LOLOLOL my tap water tastes disgusting so I do buy bottled water I admit it but I can assure you no one would think I work out and I am healthy so it most definately isnt for image..... I think people who pay over a pound for a coffee or tea are silly when they have it at home LOL....surely thats just for image !!! lol

Score: 6

John Davison

4:08pm on 18/8/2012

Fully agree Jo. Nobody is ever going to accuse me of working out these days. I do draw the line at paying more than 17p for 2 litres though. Look at Evian spelt in reverse. That is the kind of person that spends nearly a quid on a littre. As for hygeine, Dave, all food packaging has meet strict guidlines and I know that all bottles go through a sterilising procedure having previously working a bottling plant.

Score: 4

Julie Crumpton

7:42pm on 18/8/2012

Jo....get your water checked out, worth a go, ours went a bit "funny tasting" and funnily enough, we had loads of free bottled water while the problem was being sorted.......I DEF don't work out, lol!....you raise a good point with buying cups of tea and coffee! ;-)

Score: 1

Jo Brierley

9:47am on 19/8/2012

Our water is treated because we are in a hard water area and there is "nothing they can do" lol. I dont buy the 17p ones I buy from where I work which is fairly reliable but works out at 30p for 2 litres. I am metred (not through choice) so it works out about the same cost as tap water and cheaper than if I filtered it. I dont buy fizzy drinks either or tea or coffee or even juice/squash as I have a lot of allergies so I think I am quids in !

chris

10:29am on 19/8/2012

Naive......brill!

Louise Smith

10:53am on 19/8/2012

I do agree with you Dave.... its called designer water, even school kids are into it.

Score: 3

Julie Crumpton

8:53am on 18/8/2012

Hahaa! Clever tho! If people are gullible enough to buy water, ANY water, that is....more fool them! They think it's healthy because it says it comes from some spring or other, maybe it has, but after its been, bottled and messed about, travelled in a lorry, exported from France or where ever , sat on a supermarket shelf for how ever long, ......mmmm! Lovely! :-) if you travel abroad, fair enough, but to BUY it here, when your already paying for water.....madness! If your tap water doesn't taste right....get on to the water people!

Score: 16
6 replies

Windows Live User

11:24am on 18/8/2012

have some sympathy for those being duped by YOur local Friendly Store

Score: 3

jimmyjedi1979

11:30am on 18/8/2012

H.mmm. Do you know they put floride in our water, don't you? Its banned in lots of countries and a common research suggests major future problems for our arterys. Not that bottled tap water would do us anygood though..

Score: 3

John Davison

4:05pm on 18/8/2012

It doesn't state on the bottle that it is spring water. I use it purely because it is better than the stuff out of my tap and convenient to keep at work where the chillers only use basic tap water anyway

Score: 3

Julie Crumpton

7:36pm on 18/8/2012

Wlu....it's up to people to decide if they want to be duped or not!

Score: 3

Julie Crumpton

7:37pm on 18/8/2012

John.....ask to have your water checked, worth a go!

Score: 1

Name witheld

2:48pm on 19/8/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Diggory Giles Penrose Stupart

9:25am on 18/8/2012

Tap water on supermarket shelves says it all today

Score: 9
2 replies

Dave Harrison

9:38am on 18/8/2012

People are stupid enough to buy it, thats whats crazy about it

Score: 9

Louise Smith

10:32am on 19/8/2012

I have had a soda stream contraption for years..... best buy ever.

Score: 2

Windows Live User

11:23am on 18/8/2012

Our Smart Price water is treated to remove chlorine, further filtered, then bottled. Should be called idiot water When is the govt going to get a grip on these cowboys who try all the tricks of trade to take money off us? Taking my business elsewhere. You should too

Score: 8
1 reply

Dave Harrison

3:54pm on 18/8/2012

It is not a question for the govt. Every time you enter a supermarket work on the basis all they want is your money. They couldn't care less how they get it . Buyer beware !!

Score: 6

Raymond Castle

11:54am on 18/8/2012

Hmmm, 17p for two litres.......probably cheaper than normal tap water anyway!

Score: 6

Peter Coates

2:35pm on 18/8/2012

Bit like the add on the front page 'free pay as you go'. Is there a contradiction here or am I missing the point.

Score: 5

Paul Grice

3:53pm on 18/8/2012

If you can't tell the difference between tap water and spring or mineral water then you should not be buying water in the first place

Score: 9

Mikel roi

11:02pm on 18/8/2012

Some water engineer once told me that the water in the thames is drunk 64 times before it reaches the sea .....! Course he could have been taking the p***! On the other hand .. glad I don't live in Lunnen town!

Score: 4
1 reply

Name witheld

2:46pm on 19/8/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Olly Olly

11:31pm on 18/8/2012

My first thought was "How dare they do that" My second thought was "Wait a minute, does it really make a difference?"

Score: 3

Louisa Gieldon

10:45am on 19/8/2012

People really need to start reading the lables. Fair enough as a cheaper alternative to the fancier waters if your tap water is yucky. People can't really complain if the labelling is clear and Tesco are not pretending it comes from an alpine spring.

Score: 3

Keith Harrison

11:36am on 19/8/2012

tesco and asda and the rest probably say ,cheers mugs

Score: 3

Name witheld

9:40am on 20/8/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 1

John Mechelen

3:28pm on 20/8/2012

So Del boy was right

Chris Carr

3:58pm on 20/8/2012

As we have the safest tap water in the world why would any one buy it bottles which have stood around in warehouses for months, sometimes years?

Score: 1

David Wragg

6:00pm on 20/8/2012

So it should be sold simply as 'filtered water' or 'chlorine-free'. Any other description is misleading.

Score: 2
Advertisement