UK & World News

  • 10 February 2012, 20:26

Tory Trio 'Ring The Alarm Bell' On NHS Reform

Three Conservative Cabinet ministers have reportedly "rung the alarm bell" over Government NHS reforms - with one apparently comparing it to the poll tax.

Influential website ConservativeHome warned the controversial planned shake-up was "electorally fatal" and that most of the plans should be scrapped.

Its editor, Tim Montgomerie, argued the package of reforms had been David Cameron's "greatest mistake" - and said there was a feeling the Prime Minister "isn't listening" to the party.

And - speaking as a senior Lib Dem source told Sky News the Conservatives had "monumentally mishandled" the reforms - Mr Montgomerie added that anticipated budget pressures "will be blamed unfairly" on the overhaul.

Mr Montgomerie wrote in the blog: "Speaking to ConservativeHome, three Tory Cabinet ministers have now also rung the alarm bell.

"One was insistent the Bill must be dropped. Another said (Health Secretary) Andrew Lansley must be replaced.

"Another likened the NHS reforms to the poll tax. The consensus is that the Prime Minister needs an external shock to wake him to the scale of the problem.

"David Cameron's greatest political achievement as leader of the opposition was to neutralise health as an issue.

"The greatest mistake of his time as Prime Minister has been to put it back at the centre of political debate."

Mr Montgomerie told Sky News: "Either they have a humiliating month where they abandon this bill, or most of this, and that is my preferred option, not an easy option, or they carry on down the path that they're on... and for every problem that occurs in the NHS from now until the election to be pinned on this bill by Labour."

Political blog Guido Fawkes quoted 'friends' of Mr Lansley as hitting back at Mr Montgomerie - who previously worked as former Tory leader Ian Duncan Smith's chief of staff - over his comments.

"Tim's sole achievement in politics was to be chief of staff to the most unpopular leader in Conservative history, so forgive us if we don't take any lessons from him," the website reported the 'friends' as saying.

"He clearly wants to take the party back to the bad old days of constant infighting and no policy.

"He should stick to talking about gay marriage and leave serious issues like the NHS to the grown-ups."

Meanwhile, a senior Lib Dem source told Sky News: "The Tories have squandered the last few months, monumentally mishandling the health professions, so that the professions we got back on board are now peeling off.

"They are failing to show any resolve with their party and running around like headless chickens because they've messed up the politics so badly."

And health minister Simon Burns told Sky News: "We have listened to people who have come up with ideas to strengthen and improve the legislation.

"(This) is the best way and the right way forward to enable the NHS to meet its challenges."

The Government has already made more than 100 changes to the Health and Social Care Bill in the face of widespread criticism.

But the concessions have failed to quell critics, including a raft of medical professional bodies such as the British Medical Association and the Royal College of Nursing.

what do you think?

13 comments

Max Monkeyspunk Beadle

1:26pm on 10/2/2012

i seem to remember the phrase 'ring fence' being used a lot by the tories when discussing the NHS in the run up to the last election. I wonder what they meant by that??

Score: 4
1 reply

Name witheld

5:49pm on 10/2/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 4

paulnaylor

1:46pm on 10/2/2012

complete mess lol

Score: 2

glencoehiker

1:48pm on 10/2/2012

I like the way the Lib/Dems are blaming the Tories for this, without them there would be no bill. Be reassured the Lib/Dems will have to shoulder their share of the blame, if it goes through!

Score: 4
1 reply

Jennie Morris

2:33pm on 10/2/2012

The lib dems will be practically extinct at the next election the only thing they should get is 30 pieces of silver

Score: 4

Geoff337

2:50pm on 10/2/2012

THE TIME HAS COME TO SACK LANSLEY if the PM does not get rid of him he will destroy what is left of the health service, by trying to introduce this bill it is his way of making the health service private

Score: 5
1 reply

Name witheld

5:47pm on 10/2/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 2

Alf Bibby

3:25pm on 10/2/2012

Did anyone actually believe Calamity Cameron when he said you can trust the Tories with the NHS The Tories have nevere liked the NHS from its conseption and will do all they can to get rid of it.

Score: 7

Tes Davies

3:38pm on 10/2/2012

The tories want a private health service, because all the suppliers to it will be owned by cons or they will be advisors to a company or will be on there boards!!

Score: 7

John Henderson

5:03pm on 10/2/2012

It seems as if at least 3 Tories have some common sense - a rare attribute to say the least.

Score: 7

HAROLD HAZELL

5:18pm on 10/2/2012

If there is no change where is the money coming from? The NHS has had got used to having a 5% to 6% increase evry year. From now on they will get only 2% as promised by the coalition. GDP is static at the moment and will not grow by more than 2% for some time to come. That means the NHS will increasingly run out of money, even with a 2% increase (after inflation of course ). That will be called "cuts" but only cuts from what the NHS would like and are not going to get. Only reform will do, and the Labour Opposition agree that is needed. However they do not spell out what reform they support. Cowards !

Score: 4

Name witheld

5:41pm on 10/2/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 5

Name witheld

5:42pm on 10/2/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 4

Name witheld

5:48pm on 10/2/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 3

Jenny Molloy

9:29pm on 10/2/2012

So why don't this bunch of tory idiots reverse the changes they made the last time they tried to destroy the nhs? And labour are as much to blame for not making the necessary changes while in power. Get rid of managers and bring back matrons and clinically trained staff to run hospitals, that alone will save billions

Score: 3

Raymond Castle

12:14pm on 11/2/2012

Mrs Thatcher + poll tax = bye bye prime minister. Mr Cameron + nhs = bye bye prime minister. He would do well to remember Mrs T.

Advertisement