UK & World News

  • 21 December 2012, 20:41

X Factor Hopeful Who Glassed Man Avoids Jail

An X Factor hopeful who was axed from the show after she glassed her boyfriendhas avoided jail.

Lucie Slater, 21, was sentenced to 51 weeks in prison suspended for two years, a two-year supervision order and 120 hours of community service.

Slater, from Ryton, Gateshead, had pleaded guilty to unlawfully wounding DJ William Aitken in June.

The couple were drinking wine together at his house when she came across a message on Facebook that she did not like, the court heard.

"We were cuddling," Mr Aitken recalled. "Next thing I knew she swung round and hit me with a glass and my face began to pour with blood."

The woman also threw a laptop across the room.

Slater then drove him to hospital, where she first claimed he had fallen down the stairs but later admitted what happened, the court was told.

Slater, a bar promotion worker, was part of girl band Quantro but they were thrown off the ITV talent show when the attack came to light.

Judge Toby Hedworth said: "Drink played a greater role than is now suggested.

"I also take into account the effect of your actions on Mr Aitken. All that he has ever sought in these proceedings was an acknowledgement of what happened."

Due to his injuries and the time he spent in hospital, Mr Aitken lost his business and modelling career, the court heard.

Mr Aitken said the experience was "life changing" and called the assault "an act of stupidness" that caused a lot of damage.

"I really did not think she was capable of something like that. We are not speaking to each other now," he said.

"I still love her and I want to know why she did it. It's a really sad love story. We did not plan our future like this. Instead of us breaking up, we have been ripped apart."

Slater was initially charged with the more serious offence of wounding with intent but her plea to the lesser charge was accepted by the prosecution.

what do you think?

11 comments

hollywoodbowden

12:22pm on 21/12/2012

Do you actually go to prison at all anymore seems impossible

Score: 19
11 replies

Mark Hussey

12:30pm on 21/12/2012

Not in the uk mate lol

Score: 16

Charles Rickards

12:43pm on 21/12/2012

Oh yes, as long as it is not a serious crime!

Score: 13

davenlesley

12:51pm on 21/12/2012

Charles .And smashing a glass in someones face is not a serious crime?? Good job she didn't fiddle benefits. That would have produced an immediate custodial sentence

Score: 14

davenlesley

12:53pm on 21/12/2012

Charles. Missed the NOT in your comment but I still think my point is valid

Score: 10

Diane Rogers

1:23pm on 21/12/2012

This county seems care more about crime involving money.Fraud etc I know that's wrong but these crimes warrent a prison sentence

Score: 13

Mark Hussey

1:46pm on 21/12/2012

If she was a mp she would just say she is to sick to jail.hard. labor is wot thay need

Score: 7

fish41

1:52pm on 21/12/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Nigel L

1:59pm on 21/12/2012

Had it been the other way around he would have been jailed - equallity my ar*e.

Score: 19

adam

3:48pm on 21/12/2012

Try not paying your TV licence and then refusing to pay a subsequent fine and you will be banged up straight away. How that is not worthy of a prison sentence,a serious prison sentence at that,is just beyond me. The judiciary in this country are just a total and utter joke.

Score: 9

surly seagull

1:16pm on 22/12/2012

You said it Louisa the sisterhod is about fairness and equality ,as long as that doesnt involve a man .So you think this is fair and equal then ,if like you say the so called sisterhood stands up for fairness etc then perhaps they should be speaking up for this male victim or dare I say it they are sexist .Why is it when a woman stands up for her sex it is standing up fer her rights ,yet when a man does it he is either over the top or a male chauvanist .Equality means being equal especially when it comes to the law and whether you agree or not ,if this was a man who had done this he would have been vilified and his picture all over the news and would have recieved a custodial sentence

Score: 7

Louisa Gieldon

7:16pm on 22/12/2012

Woah surly seagull. You are certainly living up to your name. I agree with your comments about equality and don't understand why you are railing at me like that. I have never she should not have gotten a custodial sentence. Equality is equality. Don't put words in my mouth that i haven't said please. By the way sometimes men do get away without a custodial sentence for this type of crime. The judge/ sherriff has all the facts before him/her and takes it all into account.

Score: 5

adam hale

1:00pm on 21/12/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Jenna Purcell

1:19pm on 21/12/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

Score: 7
1 reply

Mark Hussey

1:33pm on 21/12/2012

Cannot see maney lads looking for a date with her

Score: 5

LucienSolo1

2:23pm on 21/12/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

blue side

2:26pm on 21/12/2012

Another area where the law is crazy - man verbally assaults woman and look out but woman physically assaults the guy as here and she walks. Seems the law has not yet accepted that the female can be as dangerous as the male

Score: 12
23 replies

Mark Hussey

3:16pm on 21/12/2012

Try going out were i live mate safer in downtown karbul. And as to how thay dress. I have seen more on a striper

Score: 8

davenlesley

4:02pm on 21/12/2012

Blue side. Too true. We are forever berated about the unaccepatbility of domestic abuse by men but in a clear case of domestic abuse by a woman she is spared prison. Whatever happened to equality ??

Score: 7

blue side

4:22pm on 21/12/2012

Diane Rogers under Hollywoodbowdens posts also makes a good point about white collar crime getting preference. Mark think Dave and I will steer clear of your area

Score: 5

davenlesley

5:14pm on 21/12/2012

Blue side. She is from up here. I hope I don't meet her in the Toon one friday night, at least not without a sawn off shotgun

Score: 4

Louisa Gieldon

6:56pm on 21/12/2012

In general, women who commit violent crime are treated more severely by the courts. It's seen as unfeminine behaviour and abhored ( as it should be for men and women )

Score: 12

Nick Eaton

7:20pm on 21/12/2012

more so Blue side I would say."a women scorned eh?)

Score: 5

Mark Hussey

7:30pm on 21/12/2012

Some how think thay may just charge you if you shoot someone lol

Score: 4

Mark Hussey

7:33pm on 21/12/2012

Louisa she glassed him and walked if a man did that he would be in jail.as for women thay are rough round here most dress worse than a striper

Score: 5

Diane Rogers

8:54pm on 21/12/2012

Mark same where I live. My sister and I used to go round town a long time ago never like it is now and thats the girls. I have just finished work had to walk through town some of them are so foul mouthed I can swear when I watch footy but never I public

Score: 5

Mark Hussey

9:11pm on 21/12/2012

Diane its the same town not to far from you

Score: 4

Diane Rogers

9:24pm on 21/12/2012

Mark now how did you know that

Score: 4

Mark Hussey

9:36pm on 21/12/2012

Diane old lfc board you were tat shrews liverbird. Marklfc

Score: 4

Diane Rogers

10:02pm on 21/12/2012

Mark how are you m8,Shrewsbury used to be a good place for a pub crawl in the 70's not now as I said girls are worse than I used to be

Score: 4

blue side

10:07pm on 21/12/2012

Society has lost something it was nice when gals were gals and blokes were blokes now it will be a long time before the pendulum swings back.

Score: 5

Mark Hussey

10:36pm on 21/12/2012

Diane i am fine and you.if i acted or said wot thay did my dad would of horse wiped my ass.i would never let my kids dress like cheep hookers

Score: 4

Diane Rogers

10:43pm on 21/12/2012

Mark exactly my dad would have been the same I have two daughter 31 and 25 I would not let them out dressed like some of these girls

Score: 4

Louisa Gieldon

7:06pm on 22/12/2012

ark i am perfectly aware that she "glassed him".I have not defended her or said that she should not be in jail. I do not much care if the women near you dress like stripers (sic) as i don't see what is relevant about that

Score: 5

Louisa Gieldon

7:08pm on 22/12/2012

I understand why people think a custodial sentence would be more appropriate.

Score: 5

Louisa Gieldon

7:09pm on 22/12/2012

Diane football matches are in public so if you think it's ok to swear there, why is it not ok to swear in the street?

Score: 5

Diane Rogers

7:59pm on 22/12/2012

Louisa. When I watch it on tv.can't go to a game now and say anything without fear of getting thrown out

Score: 3

Louisa Gieldon

8:44pm on 22/12/2012

Not criticising you for swearing Diane. I'm a Glaswegian Catholic and despite not quite qualifying as trailer trash, i swear like a trooper! My pal has what we call Football tourettes and will be thrown out one day!

Score: 5

Mark Hussey

9:59pm on 22/12/2012

Louisa wot me and diane were saying is how much shrewsbery as changed over the last ten years or more women back then used to act like ladys now i have seen. Better dressed stripers .and its. saferin

Score: 3

Chris Robinson

12:56am on 24/12/2012

This comment has been removed for violations of our Terms and Conditions.

RayMcGlynn

3:04pm on 21/12/2012

Look a nice couple!

Score: 3

Kelly Curtis

3:28pm on 21/12/2012

even if it is first offence,THAT deserves some prison time punishment ! he has lost his career and income,yet she does not have to compensate him financially and can carry on happily with a clean record ! is that justice ?

Score: 14

surly seagull

3:38pm on 21/12/2012

Well more proof of the discrimination men face in our society. Could you just imagine the blood curdling cries of hatred and hang him high from the sacred coven of sister hood if this was the other way round .

Score: 15
7 replies

davenlesley

3:59pm on 21/12/2012

SS. Yes I can. She is pretty to look at and had she been disfigured by a glass wielding man that is the first thing the sisterhood would have thrown up. Glassing someone are the actions of a coward

Score: 9

Louisa Gieldon

6:52pm on 21/12/2012

Boys, boys, you really have got the "sIsterhood" all wrong.Being pretty doesn't make a scarring worse. And an assault is an assault regardless of the gender of the attacker. "Sisterhood" is about fairness and equality and not the silly and vnidictive situation you both describe

Score: 8

LucienSolo1

7:18pm on 21/12/2012

Do you think she should have received a custodial sentence Louisa?

Score: 5

davenlesley

8:30pm on 21/12/2012

Louisa. I don't think we have the reaction wrong at all. Had this been done to her the first thing being bandied about would be how this pretty girl has been scarred for life by this vicious man. I do go along with you on the question of assault though. The sex of the attacker is irrelevant and this type of assault calls for a custodial sentence immediately

Score: 6

Diane Rogers

9:10pm on 21/12/2012

I agree with all you fellas if it was the other way round all the women libbers would have been up in arms

Score: 6

blue side

10:01pm on 21/12/2012

Diane is right so let us boys burn our J Straps and march on the local. :-) but as Louisa says this case is about equality of justice or lack of

Score: 6

Louisa Gieldon

7:03pm on 22/12/2012

Lucien, i think if it was a first offence the sentence is probably appropriate but i would have supported a custodial snetence too, if the judge had felt it appropriate as he/she had all the facts before them.

Score: 5

LucienSolo1

3:50pm on 21/12/2012

Yes I really believe she should have received a custodial sentence and been made to pay him compensation. I agree wholheartedly with those who say is it was the man who had done it to her, there would have been an outcry. He can of course sue her, but he loves her doesn't he?

Score: 9
1 reply

davenlesley

10:33pm on 21/12/2012

Lucien. I am with you all the way but find your last sentance rather ironic. In so many instances of domestic violence against women that is the very reason the victims give for not taking the perpetrator to court. She loves him and he has promised to change. In your dreams girls, get out while you can

Score: 4

movvi

2:50pm on 22/12/2012

Another romantic evening spent trawling Fakebook and actually being shocked at what can be found written there by others with little better to do. Classy. It looks to me like that glass was shoved into his face with some force. Also, throwing a laptop as well suggests a very real anger / temper problem. I do think society needs protecting from that one!

Score: 6

t.bulgin

5:10pm on 22/12/2012

Are we sure that it was a glass ? or did she attack him with that chin ?

Score: 5
Advertisement